Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Australian Stock Exchange  >  Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited    ANZ   AU000000ANZ3


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

Natixis bank broadens metals fraud lawsuit, targets Glencore unit

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
12/18/2017 | 09:52am EDT
The logo of commodities trader Glencore is pictured in front of the company's headquarters in Baar

(The online version of this Dec. 15 story corrects conversion in paragraph one to 24 million pounds, NOT 24 billion pounds)

By Eric Onstad

Glencore's warehouse unit Access World rejected the accusations, according to the court papers.

The move increases the focus on Access World, which said in January it had become aware of fake warehouse receipts circulating in its name and urged holders to seek authentication.

In May, Natixis launched a lawsuit against metals broker Marex Spectron for $32 million after the bank said it paid the broker for metal but the ownership receipts provided by Marex for nickel stored in a warehouse turned out to be fakes.

Marex rejected the claim and issued a counterclaim against Glencore's unit Access World, which stored the metal. Marex said it had been diligent in verifying the warrants and that the warehouse firm had confirmed the receipts were authentic.

"Some further particulars having been provided by Marex, the bank has now brought the claims against Access World," Natixis said in a court document filed on Dec. 7.

Natixis had no immediate comment. Marex and Glencore declined to comment.

Metals markets were rocked about three years ago by a $3 billion fraud at Qingdao port in China, when a firm allegedly duplicated warehouse certificates to pledge metal as collateral for multiple bank loans.

Following the more recent fraud, some global banks briefly froze credit lines for Singapore metal traders, people familiar with the matter said at the time.


The Natixis legal action revolves around a series of complex trades in nickel warehouse receipts in late 2016 and early 2017 in which the bank granted what amounted to loans using nickel as collateral.

Warehouse receipts can be endorsed from one holder to another and in this case the documents were transferred between several parties before they were discovered to be fakes.

Marex said it verified some of the documents by sending them by courier to Access World's office in Singapore.

The warehouse company acknowledged in court papers that on Dec. 22, 2016 and on Jan. 9, 2017 it certified that the receipts were valid, but raised the possibility that they were not the same documents that were shown to be fakes in February.

"As soon as the warehouse receipt leaves Access World's possession, it will have to be re-authenticated by Access World on any subsequent presentation," it said in a court filing on Sept. 15.

Fake warehouse receipts for metal stored in Access World depots have also spurred legal action from Australia and New Zealand Banking Group, which was involved in a similar loan deal using nickel as collateral.

Unlike Natixis, ANZ has sued neither its broker, ED&F Man, nor Access World, but said in U.S. court papers it was targeting parties in Asia it suspected were behind the fraud.

ANZ was not immediately available for comment and ED&F Man declined to comment.

ANZ received permission from the U.S. District Court in San Francisco to interview U.S. witnesses linked to Asian firms involved in the nickel trades, a court filing in August showed.

ANZ, Australia's third-biggest lender, said in the court papers that it had already unearthed information in Hong Kong after it asked courts there for access to bank records.

Those bank documents, included in the U.S. court filing, showed transfers of $151 million from two Hong Kong firms involved in the nickel trades to people and entities in California.

The two Hong Kong firms - Come Harvest Holdings Ltd (CHH) and Mega Wealth International Trading Ltd - were clients of ED&F Man and handed over the warehouse receipts in exchange for loans.

One of them, CHH, was also a client of Marex and provided the warehouse receipts for the transactions with Natixis, the British court documents show.

CHH and Mega Wealth were not available for comment.

(Reporting by Eric Onstad; Editing by Edmund Blair)

Stocks treated in this article : Natixis, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group, Glencore
Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND BANKING GROUP LIMITED -4.54% 17.89 End-of-day quote.-27.37%
GLENCORE PLC -4.72% 149.82 Delayed Quote.-36.34%
LETS HOLDINGS GROUP CO., LTD. 4.01% 12.45 End-of-day quote.106.13%
NATIXIS -5.99% 1.993 Real-time Quote.-49.65%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
05/28APRA Preparing for Potential Fallout When Government Relief Measures End
05/26RBNZ Says Pandemic to Test Resilience of New Zealand Banks
05/26RBNZ Says Pandemic to Test Resilience of New Zealand Banks --Update
05/25AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND BANKING : ANZ - wholesale debt ANZHAU - interest payme..
05/25TRANSCRIPT : Shayne Elliott with Neil Mitchell - 3AW
05/20Coronavirus crushes Australia's dividends with banks leading the decline
05/19AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND BANKING : ANZ - wholesale debt ANZHAT - interest payme..
05/18Aussie Banks Face Rising Risk as Deferral Deadline Looms
05/14Vietnam's Techcombank takes $500 million syndicated loan from foreign lenders
05/11TRANSCRIPT : Shayne Elliott with Tom Elliott - 3AW Drive
More news
Sales 2020 18 079 M 12 050 M 12 050 M
Net income 2020 3 736 M 2 490 M 2 490 M
Net Debt 2020 - - -
P/E ratio 2020 13,9x
Yield 2020 2,41%
Capitalization 50 650 M 33 627 M 33 758 M
EV / Sales 2019
Capi. / Sales 2020 2,80x
Nbr of Employees 37 834
Free-Float 99,7%
Duration : Period :
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 15
Average target price 19,48 AUD
Last Close Price 17,89 AUD
Spread / Highest target 39,7%
Spread / Average Target 8,88%
Spread / Lowest Target -36,0%
EPS Revisions
Shayne Cary Elliott Chief Executive Officer & Executive Director
David M. Gonski Chairman
Michelle Jablko Chief Financial Officer
Gerard Florian Group Executive-Technology
Paula Jane Dwyer Independent Non-Executive Director