Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Bolsa de Madrid  >  Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria, SA    BBVA   ES0113211835


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

Spanish mortgage index used during crisis could be deemed abusive - ECJ advisor

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
09/10/2019 | 08:39am EDT
The logo of the European Court of Justice is pictured outside the main courtroom in Luxembourg

MADRID (Reuters) - The IRPH mortgage price index used during Spain's property crisis and blamed for home buyers being overcharged billions of euros could be considered abusive when not presented clearly, the advocate general of the European Court of Justice said on Tuesday.

By Jesús Aguado

The ruling is non-binding but could have implications for Caixabank and other Spanish banks - which still hold IRPH-derived mortgages valued at more than 16.5 billion euros (14.74 billion pounds) - including possibly having to pay compensation in some cases.

Such rulings are often followed up on by the court, which is expected to reach a final decision by early 2020 on IRPH, which was scrapped by the government in 2013.

Shares in Spanish banks fell after the advocate's conclusions were published, but later rebounded. Caixabank, Banco Sabadell and Bankia were all up by around 2% by 1220 GMT.

Spanish-based broker Alantra said in a note to clients that "if the final ECJ ruling goes in the same direction, we would not expect immediate losses for the banks in the 2019 accounts as this litigation risk would play out over several years".

Spanish banks are already under pressure due to low interest rates, which have squeezed their margins.

While analysing the level of transparency in IRPH contractual clauses, the advocate said its "mathematical calculation formula is complex and not very transparent for an average consumer".

Hundreds of thousands of mortgages set using this rate were sold, particularly in 2007 and 2008, but it tended to be higher than Euribor and did not fall as much when the European Central Bank cut borrowing costs.

"The advocate is basically paving the way to recognise that IRPH could be considered abusive," a spokesman for the ECJ court said.

The Spanish government scrapped the index six years ago saying it was unfair, leading customers to take banks to court demanding compensation.

Spanish courts have rejected these appeals, but a question focusing on the lack of transparency when selling mortgages with this clause had been lodged at the European Court of Justice.


On Tuesday, Spain's acting Economy Minister Nadia Calvino said that the opinion from the advocate did not anticipate the final ruling. "We have to wait for the (final ruling) and the consequence for the Spanish courts, which are the ones that are going to decide on a case by case basis," Calvino said.

Spanish consumer associations, such as OCU, which estimated that banks had overcharged clients 37 billion euros by using the index, welcomed the news and shared the view from the advocate that control must be guaranteed on potential abusive clauses.

The Bank of Spain recently warned of a potential impact on Spanish banks' profits related to the IRPH.

Though there are no official figures for how many mortgages were sold under the IRPH, Spanish consumer association Asufin put the number of affected clients at around 1 million.

Goldman Sachs estimates a potential cost to the banking sector of between 7 billion and 44 billion euros.

On Tuesday, Credit Suisse said the opinion would prolong uncertainty for banks. The impact of an adverse ruling would be hard to quantify, it said, as it depended on a set of factors which were not known yet, such as what the IRPH index will be replaced with, whether retroactivity applies and, if so, until what date; and what amount of mortgages will be impacted.

Spanish banks have so far defended the validity of the IRPH, which they say was an official measure approved and published by the Bank of Spain.

The lender most exposed to this clause is Caixabank with up to 6.5 billion euros, followed by Santander, with 4.3 billion euros and BBVA with 3.1 billion euros though bigger lenders have a more diversified business model.

Bankia and Sabadell also have hefty exposures of 1.6 billion euros and 830 million, respectively.

Caixabank, Bankia and Sabadell declined to comment on the conclusions.

(Reporting By Jesús Aguado; additional reporting by Emma Pinedo; editing by Ingrid Melander/Andrey Khalip/Susan Fenton)

By Jesús Aguado

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA, SA -1.45% 4.795 End-of-day quote.3.44%
BANCO DE SABADELL, S.A. -1.64% 0.897 End-of-day quote.-10.34%
BANCO SANTANDER, S.A. -1.44% 3.766 End-of-day quote.-5.21%
BANKIA, SA -1.90% 1.7305 End-of-day quote.-32.40%
CAIXABANK, S.A. -0.79% 2.385 End-of-day quote.-24.62%
LIBERBANK SA -2.47% 0.3 End-of-day quote.-31.82%
UNICAJA BANCO SA -0.14% 0.7255 End-of-day quote.-36.91%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
09/12'NOT ENOUGH : ' Investors react to Pemex bond plan
09/10Spanish mortgage index used during crisis could be deemed abusive - ECJ advis..
09/03Deutsche Boerse promoted to euro-zone blue-chip stocks index in reshuffle
08/28BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA : Offer of securities contingently convertible
08/22EUROPE : European shares end lower in choppy session, FTSE lags
08/15Euro zone bank share meltdown brings prices to brink of 1980s
08/08BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA : BBVA Sells Paraguay Business for $270 Million
07/31BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA : Consolidated financial statements, management ..
07/31BBVA 2Q Net Profit Rose, Beating Expectations -- Update
07/31BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA : Correction to BBVA Earnings Article
More news
Financials (EUR)
Sales 2019 24 045 M
EBIT 2019 12 174 M
Net income 2019 4 456 M
Debt 2019 -
Yield 2019 5,60%
P/E ratio 2019 7,28x
P/E ratio 2020 7,21x
Capi. / Sales2019 1,33x
Capi. / Sales2020 1,31x
Capitalization 31 896 M
Duration : Period :
Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria, SA Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGEN
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 26
Average target price 5,67  €
Last Close Price 4,80  €
Spread / Highest target 57,5%
Spread / Average Target 18,3%
Spread / Lowest Target -18,9%
EPS Revisions
Onur Genç Chief Executive Officer
Carlos Torres Vila Executive Chairman
Jaime Saenz de Tejada Pulido Chief Financial Officer
Carlos Loring Martínez de Irujo External Director
José Maldonado Ramos External Director
Sector and Competitors