By David French
U.S. securities filings show that only four of 12 listed oil and gas companies that received emergency government aid made available for small businesses said they would return it ahead of a deadline for firms that do not need the funds to do so.
The U.S. Treasury Department offered amnesty to public companies that return money they borrowed by May 18, saying it would deem they made the application in good faith due to economic uncertainty fueled by the coronavirus outbreak, before guidelines were clarified.
The U.S. energy sector has been clamoring for government aid in the wake of plummeting oil prices that have driven several debt-laden exploration and production companies into bankruptcy.
While President Donald Trump said last month his administration would formulate a plan to help the oil and gas industry, no specific aid has been announced. This has left energy companies to seek relief under the broader $2.3 trillion U.S. stimulus package.
One aspect of the latter that has been used by oil and gas firms is the so-called Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) for small businesses, which provides loans that can be forgiven to cover payroll expenses, as well as mortgage interest, rent and utility costs.
Denver-based exploration and production company PDC Energy Inc, which has a market capitalization of $1.3 billion, said on May 8 it had returned its $10 million PPP loan.
Natural Gas Services Group also returned its $4.6 million PPP loan. Its chief executive, Stephen Taylor, said the Midland, Texas-based compression equipment provider had to cut 20% of its workforce after it returned the funds.
Public companies and their employees were being "discriminated against" by a "politically driven process," Taylor told analysts during the company's May 7 earnings call.
Dawson Geophysical Co returned its $6.4 million PPP loan last week, the company said in a May 14 filing. Midland-based Dawson, which produces seismic data for oil and gas firms, cited "an abundance of caution" and new guidance for the decision.
Calumet Specialty Products, an Indianapolis-based refiner that received $31.4 million through five PPP applications, said Tuesday it repaid its loans by the deadline, also due to the "subsequently-changed guidance."
Among those receiving loans, but which had not disclosed whether they would return the funds as of Monday, were exploration firms Amplify Energy Corp and Battalion Oil Corp, which received $5.5 million and $2.2 million respectively. Houston-based onshore driller Independence Contract Drilling got a $10 million PPP loan.
The quartet, along with the other five listed oil and gas firms that received PPP loans, did not respond to requests for comment.
Energy companies have also benefited from emergency tax reform enacted due to the pandemic.
More than $2 billion of benefits were recorded by a combined 43 companies due to two changes in the tax code, including one allowing current losses to be offset against past income tax bills, a Reuters review of first-quarter earnings statements found.
(Reporting by David French in New York; Editing by Greg Roumeliotis, Kenneth Maxwell and Dan Grebler)