Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  SHENZHEN STOCK EXCHANGE  >  Huawei Culture Co Ltd    002502   CNE100000WQ5


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener StrategiesAnalyst Recommendations

Explainer: Why is Huawei seeking $1 billion patent deal with Verizon?

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
06/14/2019 | 07:10am EDT
FILE PHOTO: A Huawei company logo is seen at CES Asia 2019 in Shanghai

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Huawei is demanding Verizon Communications Inc pay $1 billion (£790.39 million) to licence the rights to patented technology, signalling a potential shift in the embattled Chinese company's strategy for the U.S. market.

A Huawei executive made the demand in a February letter, a person briefed on the matter told Reuters. The Wall Street Journal first reported on the letter on Wednesday. The fee would cover licensing of more than 230 patents.

Verizon spokesman Rich Young declined to comment “regarding this specific issue because it’s a potential legal matter.”

However, Young said, “These issues are larger than just Verizon. Given the broader geopolitical context, any issue involving Huawei has implications for our entire industry and also raise national and international concerns.”

Huawei did not respond to a request for comment.

The following explains why the patent dispute is not unusual and how it could be resolved.

How common is patent licensing?

Patent licensing is very common, particularly in complex industries like telecommunications. As technology has advanced, it has become harder to avoid violating — or "infringing" — patent rights. There are millions of U.S. patents in force, and a typical smartphone implicates hundreds of thousands of them.

Companies like Apple Inc, Nokia Inc and Qualcomm Inc own many thousands of patents issued by governments around the world.

It is not unusual for these firms to try to make money from their massive patent portfolios. Nokia, for example, routinely brings in more than $1 billion a year from licensing its patents to others.

Large companies like Verizon will try to identify patents they might be violating, said Gaston Kroub, a patent lawyer in New York. But that can be a challenge because so many patents are granted every year, Kroub said.

"Sophisticated companies like Verizon understand that they could be approached by licensors of any stripe at any time," Kroub said. The philosophy of wireless carriers and smartphone companies, Kroub said, can be "let's deal with these claims as they arrive, because we don't know who will knock on our door next."

Tom Cotter, a professor of patent law at the University of Minnesota, said it was possible Huawei executives believe Verizon has been infringing their U.S. patents for some time but for business reasons waited until now to seek compensation.

Patent owners "may not enforce their patents for a period of time, but they can choose do to so whenever they want to," Cotter said. "It happens all the time."

What happens if Verizon does not pay?

Huawei may end up going to a U.S. court and suing Verizon for alleged patent infringement.

While some licensing disputes are resolved without lawsuits, litigation is fairly common. Huawei and Samsung Electronics Co recently settled a global legal battle on confidential terms.

A defendant in a patent case typically argues that it does not actually infringe the asserted patents, or that they were mistakenly issued and should be revoked.

In a lawsuit, a patent owner can ask a judge to block sales of infringing products. While such injunctions are rarely granted in the United States, the threat of one can motivate a defendant to settle with the patent owner.

Legal experts said Huawei is likely prepared to go to court.

"I don't know how you can make a demand of $1 billion and not be prepared for the answer to be no, at least at first, and for the need to litigate," Kroub said.

Has Huawei been an aggressive enforcer of its patents?

Huawei has long been known for defending itself against U.S. patent infringement claims, rather than bringing them. But that could be changing.

George Koomullil, a patent analyst at Pleasanton, California-based technology company Relecura, said that 10 or 15 years ago Huawei applied for a relatively modest number of patents. But the company has been more aggressive about applying for patents since around 2007, and particularly in recent years, Koomullil said.

Huawei may be more inclined to monetize its U.S. patents now that the U.S. government has limited its ability to sell products in the country, Kroub said.

The National Defense Authorization Act last year placed a broad ban on the use of federal money to purchase products from Huawei, citing national security concerns.

Last month, the Trump administration banned Huawei from buying vital U.S. technology without special approval and effectively barring its equipment from U.S. telecom networks.

Kroub said Huawei's licensing demand could reflect a "desperation to come up with ways of generating revenue in the U.S. market, especially considering the traditional ways of offering products and selling things to business is closed to them."

Franklin Turner, a government contracts lawyer at McCarter & English in Washington, said the patent licensing demand may also be a way for Huawei to "retaliate" against the United States.

Republican Senator Marco Rubio said on Twitter on Thursday that the demand against Verizon was an "attempt by (Huawei) to retaliate against the U.S. by setting the stage for baseless, but costly, patent claims."

(Reporting by Jan Wolfe; Additional reporting by David Sherpardson and Karen Freifeld; Editing by Cynthia Osterman)

By Jan Wolfe

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
APPLE -1.49% 202.59 Delayed Quote.28.43%
HUAWEI CULTURE CO LTD End-of-day quote.
NOKIA OYJ 0.66% 4.5815 Delayed Quote.-9.51%
QUALCOMM 0.85% 75 Delayed Quote.30.68%
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS -1.08% 56.59 Delayed Quote.0.66%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
07/15GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Facebook, Gilead, AB Inbev, Boeing…
07/10GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Airbus dominates Boeing, Tech giants under surveillance, B..
07/05GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Osram, Samsung, Huawei, Amazon…
06/20HUAWEI CULTURE : WIMI Hologram AR and SenseTime committed to Hologram AI Unmanne..
06/18HUAWEI CULTURE : WiMi Hologram AR, MEGVII, SenseTime and CLOUDWALK compete for T..
06/17HUAWEI CULTURE : WiMi AR Hologram and MEGVII AI-enabled Facial Recognition fire ..
06/17GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Nissan, Huawei, Deutsche Bank, Pfizer…
06/14EXPLAINER : Why is Huawei seeking $1 billion patent deal with Verizon?
06/14GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Huawei, Walmart, Sony, Huawei…
06/10GLOBAL MARKETS LIVE : Renault, Nissan, Raytheon, United Technologies…
More news
Financials (CNY)
Sales 2018 -
EBIT 2018 -
Net income 2018 -
Debt 2018 -
Yield 2018 -
P/E ratio 2018 -
P/E ratio 2019 -
Capi. / Sales2018 -
Capi. / Sales2019 -
Capitalization 2 906 M
Duration : Period :
Huawei Culture Co Ltd Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus -
Number of Analysts
Average target price
Last Close Price 3,38  CNY
Spread / Highest target -
Spread / Average Target -
Spread / Lowest Target -
EPS Revisions
Xiang Bin Guo Vice Chairman & General Manager
Zhuo Cai Guo Chairman
Li Qiao Lin Chairman-Supervisory Board
Chu Jun Chen Chief Financial Officer, Director & Deputy GM
Sheng Ping Li Independent Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
TOHO CO LTD (TOKYO)18.33%7 697
CHINA FILM CO LTD-1.26%3 838