Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  NATIONAL STOCK EXCHANGE OF INDIA  >  Tata Steel    TATASTEEL   INE081A01012


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

Tata Steel : Latest profit warning challenges Thyssenkrupp spin-off logic

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
11/09/2018 | 10:04am EDT
FILE PHOTO: A logo of ThyssenKrupp AG is pictured outside their headquarters in Essen

FRANKFURT/DUESSELDORF (Reuters) - Thyssenkrupp shares fell to a two-year low on Friday after the German conglomerate cut its profit forecast for the second time this year, raising doubts over a planned deal to split the steel-to-elevators group in two.

By Christoph Steitz, Edward Taylor and Tom Käckenhoff

The profit warning late on Thursday is the second under Guido Kerkhoff, installed as the group's permanent chief executive in July after a tumultuous summer that featured the resignation of the group's chairman and former CEO following mounting shareholder disquiet.

It is expected to put further pressure on Kerkhoff, who is struggling to get markets excited about a landmark move to split up the group via a spin off of its elevator, car parts and plant engineering units, as no part of the business is without issues.

"I'm still sceptical over whether the split is the right decision," said Thomas Hechtfischer, managing director of shareholder advisory group DSW, which usually represents 1 percent of Thyssenkrupp's voting rights at its annual meeting.

"It will be difficult to convey how things are supposed to move forward when a new can of worms has just been opened."

Shares fell as much as 12.2 percent to their lowest level since July 2016. They were down 9.8 percent at 1450 GMT.

Thyssenkrupp's current enterprise value of around 15 billion euros ($17 billion) is roughly the same as its elevator business if viewed on a standalone basis, analysts say, with the risk of a bidder coming in to break up the business.


The company, whose roots go back more than 200 years, on Thursday said it had decided to set aside risk provisions for a probe by the country's cartel office into alleged agreements relating to heavy plate and flat carbon steel products.

"We have taken this matter very seriously from the very beginning and, with the help of an external law firm, conducted our own internal investigation," board member Donatus Kaufmann said in a letter to employees that was obtained by Reuters.

As a result, net income in the financial year 2017/18 is expected to drop to 100 million euros, down 63 percent from the 271 million last year. The group had previously expected a significant rise in net profit.

Kaufmann said the provisions would have no impact on a planned 50-50 European joint venture with Tata Steel and that the cartel investigation relates to legacy cases.

"All persons involved are no longer working in their areas of responsibility or have left the company," the company said.

In addition, the group set aside provisions for risks arising from quality issues at its automotive business, including higher manufacturing expenses and warranty costs. It also pointed to shipping restrictions at its steel unit and warned of lower-than-expected earnings at its elevator unit.

This partly challenges the logic behind Thyssenkrupp's plans to spin-off elevators and car parts into one division, separating them from other assets within the group.

The group now expects adjusted earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) to fall to 1.6 billion euros, down from a previous target of 1.8 billion. Thyssenkrupp will present full-year results on Nov. 21.

(Editing by Kirsten Donovan/Keith Weir)

By Christoph Steitz, Edward Taylor and Tom Käckenhoff

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
TATA STEEL -1.64% 534.2 End-of-day quote.2.52%
THYSSENKRUPP -3.30% 13.17 Delayed Quote.-9.08%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
Latest news on TATA STEEL
04/18TATA STEEL : structural hollow steel brand ‘Tata Structura' is now a Super..
04/17TATA STEEL : recognised as 2018 Steel Sustainability Champion
04/11TATA STEEL : Bara Tertiary Treatment Plant wins the 'Industrial Water Project of..
04/09TATA STEEL : Sponge acquires the steel business of Usha Martin
04/09TATA STEEL : Karate Training Centre Brings Laurels for Team India
04/06TATA STEEL : 4QFY19 and FY19 - Key Production and Sales Figure (Provisional)
04/05TATA STEEL : wins the 'Gobal Slag Company of the Year' award at the 14th Global ..
04/04EUROPE : European stocks snap winning run, Commerzbank in merger focus
04/03TATA STEEL : Thyssenkrupp workers want guarantees should Tata Steel deal dissolv..
04/02EUROPE : European stocks hit six-month high as automakers, insurers gain
More news
Financials (INR)
Sales 2019 1 612 B
EBIT 2019 213 B
Net income 2019 95 669 M
Debt 2019 1 023 B
Yield 2019 1,83%
P/E ratio 2019 6,71
P/E ratio 2020 7,69
EV / Sales 2019 1,04x
EV / Sales 2020 0,99x
Capitalization 649 B
Duration : Period :
Tata Steel Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends TATA STEEL
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 25
Average target price 588  INR
Spread / Average Target 10%
EPS Revisions
Thachat Viswanath Narendran Chief Executive Officer, Executive Director & MD
Natarajan Chandrasekaran Chairman
Koushik Chatterjee Chief Financial Officer & Executive Director
Ashok Kumar Chief Technology Officer-Process
Vinay V. Mahashabde Chief Technical Officer-Flat Products
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
TATA STEEL2.52%9 306
POSCO--.--%20 240
NUCOR9.98%17 525