Log in
E-mail
Password
Remember
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Settings
Settings
Dynamic quotes 
OFFON

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Toronto Stock Exchange  >  The Bank of Nova Scotia    BNS   CA0641491075

THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA

(BNS)
  Report
SummaryQuotesChartsNewsRatingsCalendarCompanyFinancialsConsensusRevisions 
News SummaryMost relevantAll newsPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector news

Bank of Nova Scotia : Canada Labour Code Adjudicator Awards Costs In Unjust Dismissal Case

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
05/29/2020 | 08:08am EDT

In P.D. and The Bank of Nova Scotia, Re, 2020 CarswellNat 640, Adjudicator Kaufman considered the issue of whether the Canada Labour Code (the "Code") authorized adjudicators to award costs in unjust dismissal cases.

The complainant P.D. worked as a customer service representative at the Bank of Nova Scotia (the "employer"). She was dismissed due to allegations that she misappropriated $1,000.00 of the Bank's funds and attempted to cover up the theft while serving customer Mr. X.

Counsel for the employer argued that there were no grounds under the Code for a costs award in an unjust dismissal claim, citing Canadian Human Rights Commission and Mowat v. Canada (Attorney General), 2011 S.C.C. 53 (CanLII) ("Mowat"). Employer's counsel argued since "costs" is a legal term of art, if Parliament intended to confer the authority to award costs then it would have been explicitly stated in the legislation.

However, Adjudicator Kaufman found that Mowat was decided specifically in the context of the Canadian Human Rights Act and the absence of a specific authority to award costs should not be generalized to other administrative bodies.

Adjudicator Kaufman reviewed the post-Mowat decision of Wilson v. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., 2016 SCC 29 (CanLII) and found that the Justices of the Supreme Court confirmed that as part of the remedial scheme set out in section 242(4) of the Code, adjudicators have the authority to award costs. The applicable provision being:

"Unjust dismissal

(4) If the Board decides under subsection (3) that a person has been unjustly dismissed, the Board may, by order, require the employer who dismissed the person to

(a) pay the person compensation not exceeding the amount of money that is equivalent to the remuneration that would, but for the dismissal, have been paid by the employer to the person;

(b) reinstate the person in his employ; and

(c) do any other like thing that it is equitable to require the employer to do in order to remedy or counteract any consequence of the dismissal."

Adjudicator Kaufman concluded that the wording "do any like thing that is equitable." conferred a broad discretion for adjudicators to award costs as is appropriate. As such she applied the factors set out in Rule 400 of the Federal Court Rules, to determine a costs award.

The appropriate scale of costs was also canvassed, based on the following factors: adjudication is a fact-finding process, the onus is on the employer to establish just cause for dismissal on a balance of probabilities if just cause is not proven the employer is at risk of compensating the complainant for their legal costs, and the purpose of costs is not to punish the employer but to "make whole" the complainant that spent resources to test their unjust dismissal.

Adjudicator Kaufman concluded that partial indemnity costs would be insufficient since P.D. had "done little to contribute to the costs she incurred, other than to have been misjudged by the employer." As a result she awarded substantial indemnity costs in the amount of $90,466.40.

Key Takeaway: Employees under the Code may have an increased chance of being awarded substantial indemnity costs in the adjudication of their matter as compared to commencing a wrongful dismissal claim at the Superior Court where costs awards are typically made at the partial indemnity rate.

If you have more questions about your wrongful dismissal, contact employment lawyer Marty Rabinovitch at 416-446-5826 or at marty.rabinovitch@devrylaw.ca

"This article is intended to inform. Its content does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon by readers as such. If you require legal assistance, please see a lawyer. Each case is unique and a lawyer with good training and sound judgment can provide you with advice tailored to your specific situation and needs."

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mr Marty Rabinovitch
Devry Smith Frank LLP
95 Barber Greene Road, Suite 100,
Toronto
ON M3C3E9
CANADA
Tel: 866474 1700
Fax: 416449 7071
E-mail: info@devrylaw.ca
URL: devrylaw.ca/

© Mondaq Ltd, 2020 - Tel. +44 (0)20 8544 8300 - http://www.mondaq.com, source Business Briefing

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
Latest news on THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA
07/10Top Canadian lenders plan to fill 3.5% of senior roles with Black employees
RE
07/10RBC commits C$150 million to diversity push, aims for more minority executive..
RE
07/09BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA : Gillian Riley, President & CEO of Tangerine Bank and EVP, ..
AQ
07/06RBC commits C$150 mln to diversity push, aims for more minority executives
RE
07/06TSX rises on energy gains, U.S. services sector rebound
RE
07/06THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA : Ex-dividend day for
FA
07/03Canada's biggest banks join boycott of Facebook platforms
RE
07/03Canada's biggest banks join boycott of Facebook platforms
RE
07/02BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA : Scotiabank and Sagicor Financial Corporation Limited to di..
PU
06/30BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA : Scotiabank launches new Sustainable Finance Group within i..
AQ
More news
Financials
Sales 2020 31 635 M 23 245 M 23 245 M
Net income 2020 5 845 M 4 295 M 4 295 M
Net Debt 2020 - - -
P/E ratio 2020 10,8x
Yield 2020 6,48%
Capitalization 67 279 M 49 482 M 49 437 M
EV / Sales 2019
Capi. / Sales 2020 2,13x
Nbr of Employees 97 369
Free-Float 99,0%
Chart THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA
Duration : Period :
The Bank of Nova Scotia Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
TrendsBearishNeutralBearish
Income Statement Evolution
Consensus
Sell
Buy
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 13
Average target price 60,77 CAD
Last Close Price 55,54 CAD
Spread / Highest target 26,0%
Spread / Average Target 9,42%
Spread / Lowest Target -20,8%
EPS Revisions
Managers
NameTitle
Brian Johnston Porter President, CEO & Non-Independent Director
Aaron William Regent Chairman
Loretta Marcoccia Chief Operating Officer, EVP-Global Banking
Rajagopal Viswanathan Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President
Michael Zerbs Chief Technology Officer & Group Head
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA-24.28%49 482
JPMORGAN CHASE & CO.-34.52%293 291
INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL BANK OF CHINA LIMITED-16.83%256 920
BANK OF AMERICA CORPORATION-31.80%208 388
CHINA CONSTRUCTION BANK CORPORATION-5.05%207 181
BANK OF CHINA LIMITED-15.62%140 810