Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  London Stock Exchange  >  The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc    RBS   GB00B7T77214


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

RBS investors call on new boss Rose to shrink NatWest Markets

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
10/09/2019 | 03:00am EDT
FILE PHOTO: People walk past a Royal Bank of Scotland office in London

LONDON (Reuters) - With weeks to go until Alison Rose takes over as CEO of Royal Bank of Scotland, shareholders are demanding a shake-up of the state-backed lender, with cuts to its minnow investment bank topping their agenda.

Rose's predecessor Ross McEwan said NatWest Markets was worth keeping for its ability to supply foreign exchange, financing and hedging to the bank's corporate clients but with profits dwindling, investors say it is ripe for cuts.

RBS's investment bank once spanned the globe with assets greater than Britain's GDP, but it also made catastrophic market bets that led to a 45 billion pound ($55 billion) taxpayer bailout during the 2007-2008 financial crisis.

Its business is now largely confined to bond trading and earns around a 1% return on equity.

The debate over RBS's investment bank comes at a time when rival Barclays faces pressure from activist investor Edward Bramson to scale back its own trading business.

Five investors told Reuters that Rose should consider shrinking NatWest Markets further as part of her bigger vision for RBS, which should also include detailed plans to tackle the threat from digital banks like Revolut.

"The big thing for me is they should look again at whether it is really worth persisting with NatWest Markets at this scale," said a top-10 investor at the bank who said he knows other shareholders who feel the same way.

NatWest Markets tied up around 35 billion pounds or 18.5% of the bank's assets while contributing just 11% of profits in the first half of the year, said Barrington Pitt-Miller, portfolio manager at Janus Henderson Investors, which has a small holding in the bank's shares.

Its 1% return on equity in the first half is below the bank's cost of capital, and with financial markets torpid in Europe and client trading subdued, there is little chance of squeezing out more profits.

"For a shareholder, purely staring at balance sheet intensity and returns, it is optically a poor business," Pitt-Miller said.

The difference now versus previous calls to scale back the investment bank is that RBS has sufficient capital buffers to absorb the losses crystallised by cutting it back, he said.

Describing NatWest Markets as one of RBS's two "problem children", together with Ulster Bank, a second major shareholder said Rose needed to decide if it was possible to improve NatWest Markets' returns "in a meaningful way ... inside the next 3-5 years".

"These consume 22% and 8% of the group's capital and basically make no money," the shareholder said.

"[RBS] are clearly doing okay at taking costs out but the revenue environment is tough and volatile. We know how hard Barclays struggles to get a decent return out of their investment bank, and that is clearly a better business than NatWest Markets," the first top-10 investor said.


Senior RBS executives agree decisions on the future for NatWest Markets will likely be taken in the coming months, with Rose broadly expected to lay out her strategy for the bank as a whole when full-year results are published in February.

The business is in the third year of a four-year turnaround, Chief Financial Officer Katie Murray told investors at a conference in September, and at the end of this restructuring its return on equity will be between 5-6%.

"It's not the endgame for where NatWest Markets will need to be," Murray said, while pointing out the value of the investment bank to business clients and the importance of continuity of service.

"We'll talk more and see over the coming months what the next stage looks like for NatWest Markets."

(Editing by Jane Merriman)

By Sinead Cruise, Simon Jessop and Lawrence White

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
BARCLAYS PLC 0.38% 164.88 Delayed Quote.9.13%
JANUS HENDERSON GROUP PLC 2.27% 22.55 Delayed Quote.6.42%
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP PLC 1.09% 232.4 Delayed Quote.6.00%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
08:37aLONDON MARKETS: British Pound Turns Lower In Volatile Trade On Concerns Parli..
05:09aROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND : NatWest reaffirms commitment to support customers throu..
04:19aBritain's finance industry at Brexit crossroads
02:17aROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND : RBS boosts Brexit contingency fund to 8.2 billion sterl..
10/16ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND : NatWest launches flagship partnership with SafeLives to..
10/16PARADOX : long-term vision vs short-term uncertainty
10/16UK banks fail to meet timetable for loan insurance claims, regulator says
10/16UK stocks retreat as market waits for Brexit deal update
10/16CURRENCY TRADING : Hopes of Brexit Deal Boost Pound, Bank Stocks -- WSJ
10/15Financials Up After JPMorgan, Citigroup Earnings - Financials Roundup
More news
Financials (GBP)
Sales 2019 12 424 M
EBIT 2019 5 370 M
Net income 2019 2 572 M
Debt 2019 -
Yield 2019 10,6%
P/E ratio 2019 10,4x
P/E ratio 2020 9,37x
Capi. / Sales2019 2,26x
Capi. / Sales2020 2,24x
Capitalization 28 043 M
Duration : Period :
The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 24
Average target price 233,32  GBp
Last Close Price 2,32  GBp
Spread / Highest target 17 902%
Spread / Average Target 9 948%
Spread / Lowest Target 6 301%
EPS Revisions
Ross Maxwell McEwan Chief Executive Officer & Executive Director
Howard John Davies Chairman
Mark Bailie Chief Operating Officer
Katie Murray Chief Financial Officer & Executive Director
Aileen N. Taylor Secretary, Director & Chief Governance Officer
Sector and Competitors