The following discussion and analysis of our financial condition and results of operations should be read together with our consolidated financial statements, the accompanying notes, and the other financial information included elsewhere in this Annual Report on Form 10-K. The following discussion contains forwardlooking statements that involve risks and uncertainties such as our plans, estimates, and beliefs. Our actual results could differ materially from those discussed in the forward-looking statements below. Factors that could cause or contribute to those differences in our actual results include, but are not limited to, those discussed below and those discussed elsewhere in this Annual Report on Form 10-K, particularly in the sections "Cautionary Notes Regarding Forward-Looking Statements" above and Part I, Item 1A. "Risk Factors" above. OverviewMesa Airlines is a regional air carrier providing scheduled passenger service to 125 cities in 39 states, theDistrict of Columbia ,Canada ,Mexico andCuba . All of our flights are operated as either American Eagle or United Express flights pursuant to the terms of capacity purchase agreements we entered into with American and United. We have a significant presence in several of our major airline partners' key domestic hubs and focus cities, includingDallas ,Houston ,Phoenix andWashington -Dulles. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we operated a fleet of 145 aircraft with approximately 730 daily departures. We operate 62 CRJ-900 aircraft under our American Capacity Purchase Agreement and 20 CRJ-700 and 60 E-175 aircraft under our United Capacity Purchase Agreement. For our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , approximately 44% of our aircraft in scheduled service were operated for American and approximately 56% were operated for United. All of our operating revenue in our 2019, 2018 and 2017 fiscal years was derived from operations associated with our American and United Capacity Purchase Agreements. Our long-term capacity purchase agreements provide us guaranteed monthly revenue for each aircraft under contract, a fixed fee for each block hour and flight actually flown, and reimbursement of certain direct operating expenses in exchange for providing regional flying on behalf of our major airline partners. Our capacity purchase agreements also shelter us from many of the elements that cause volatility in airline financial performance, including fuel prices, variations in ticket prices, and fluctuations in number of passengers. In providing regional flying under our capacity purchase agreements, we use the logos, service marks, flight crew uniforms and aircraft paint schemes of our major airline partners. Our major airline partners control route selection, pricing, seat inventories, marketing and scheduling, and provide us with ground support services, airport landing slots and gate access.
2019 Financial Highlights
For our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , we had total operating revenues of$723.4 million , a 6.1% increase, compared to$681.6 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . Net income for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 was$47.6 million , or$1.36 per diluted share, compared to net income of$33.3 million , or$1.32 per diluted share, for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . We recorded two one-time adjustments in fiscal 2019. The first was$9.5 million of non-cash lease termination expense related to our acquisition of ten CRJ-700 aircraft, which were previously leased under our aircraft lease facility withWells Fargo Bank Northwest, National Association , as owner trustee and lessor (the "GECAS Lease Facility"). The second adjustment was$3.6 million of loss on extinguishment of debt related to repayment of the Company's Spare Engine Facility 2019.
During our 2019 fiscal year, we increased our completed block hours by 45,273,
or 11.0%, compared to our fiscal year ended
Industry Trends
We believe our operating and business performance is driven by various factors that typically affect regional airlines and their markets, including trends which affect the broader airline and travel industries, though our capacity purchase agreements reduce our exposure to fluctuations in certain trends. The following key factors may materially affect our future performance. 38 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Availability and Training of Qualified Pilots. OnJuly 8, 2013 , as directed by theU.S. Congress , theFAA issued more stringent pilot qualification and crew member flight training standards, which, among other things, increased the required training time for new airline pilots from 250 hours to 1,500 hours of flight time. With these changes, the supply of qualified pilot candidates eligible for hiring by the airline industry has been dramatically reduced. To address the diminished supply of qualified pilot candidates, regional airlines implemented significant pilot wage and bonus increases. In prior periods, these factors caused our pilot attrition rates to be higher than our ability to hire and retain replacement pilots and resulted in being unable to provide flight services at or exceeding the minimum flight operating levels expected by our major airline partners. However, inJuly 2017 , we reached a new four-year collective bargaining agreement with our pilots that provides increases in our pilots' wages, premium pay for flying on scheduled days off and competitive signing bonuses for prospective new pilots. Following the ratification of our new collective bargaining agreement, our average number of new pilot applications per month during our 2019 and 2018 fiscal year exceeded pilot attrition. Our results of operations may be negatively impacted if we are unable to hire and train our pilots in a timely manner. Pilot Attrition. In recent years, we have experienced significant volatility in our attrition as a result of pilot wage and bonus increases at other regional air carriers, the growth of cargo, low-cost and ultra low-cost carriers and the number of pilots at major airlines reaching the statutory mandatory retirement age of 65 years. If our actual pilot attrition rates are materially different than our projections, our operations and financial results could be materially and adversely affected.
Economic Conditions, Challenges and Risks
Market Volatility. The airline industry is volatile and affected by economic cycles and trends. Consumer confidence and discretionary spending, fear of terrorism or war, weakening economic conditions, fare initiatives, fluctuations in fuel prices, labor actions, changes in governmental regulations on taxes and fees, weather and other factors have contributed to a number of reorganizations, bankruptcies, liquidations and business combinations among major and regional airlines. The effect of economic cycles and trends may be somewhat mitigated by our reliance on capacity purchase agreements. If, however, any of our major airline partners experiences a prolonged decline in the number of passengers or is negatively affected by low ticket prices or high fuel prices, it may seek rate reductions in future capacity purchase agreements, or materially reduce our scheduled flights in order to reduce its costs. Our financial performance could be negatively impacted by any adverse changes to the rates, number of aircraft or utilization under our capacity purchase agreements. Labor. The airline industry is heavily unionized. The wages, benefits and work rules of unionized airline industry employees are determined by collective bargaining agreements. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , approximately 75.6% of our workforce was represented by the ALPA and AFA. Our pilots and flight attendants ratified new four-year collective bargaining agreements during calendar 2017. The agreements include rate increases for three years and two years, respectively, after the amendable dates. The new agreements are amendable following their four-year term and include labor rate structures for two years (flight attendants) and three years (pilots), respectively, after the amendable dates. The terms and conditions of our future collective bargaining agreements may be affected by the results of collective bargaining negotiations at other airlines that may have a greater ability, due to larger scale, greater efficiency or other factors, to bear higher costs than we can. In addition, conflicts between airlines and their unions can lead to work slowdowns or stoppages. A strike or other significant labor dispute with our unionized employees may adversely affect our ability to conduct business. Competition. The airline industry is highly competitive. We compete principally with other regional airlines. Major airlines typically award capacity purchase agreements to regional airlines based on the following criteria: ability to fly contracted schedules, availability of labor resources, including pilots, low operating cost, financial resources, geographical infrastructure, overall customer service levels relating to on-time arrival and flight completion percentages and the overall image of the regional airline. Our ability to renew our existing agreements and earn additional flying opportunities in the future will depend, in significant part, on our ability to maintain a low-cost structure competitive with other regional air carriers. Maintenance Contracts, Costs and Timing. Our employees perform routine airframe and engine maintenance along with periodic inspections of equipment at their respective maintenance facilities. We also use third-party vendors, such as AAR,Aviall , Bombardier,GE and StandardAero, for certain heavy airframe and engine maintenance work, along with parts procurement and component overhaul services for our aircraft fleet. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 ,$59.9 million of parts inventory was consigned to us by AAR andAviall under long-term contracts that is not reflected on our balance sheet. 39 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The average age of our E-175, CRJ-900 and CRJ-700 type aircraft is approximately 3.9, 13.0 and 15.7 years, respectively. Due to the relatively young age of our E-175 aircraft, they require less maintenance now than they will in the future. Over the past five years, we have incurred relatively low maintenance expenses on our E-175 aircraft because most of the parts are under multi-year warranties and a limited number of heavy airframe checks and engine overhauls have occurred. As our E-175 aircraft age and these warranties expire, we expect that maintenance costs will increase in absolute terms and as a percentage of revenue. In addition, because our current aircraft were acquired over a relatively short period of time, significant maintenance events scheduled for these aircraft will occur at roughly the same intervals, meaning we will incur our most expensive scheduled maintenance obligations across our present fleet at approximately the same time. These more significant maintenance activities result in out-of-service periods during which aircraft are dedicated to maintenance activities and unavailable for flying under our capacity purchase agreements. We use the direct expense method of accounting for our maintenance of regional jet engine overhauls, airframe, landing gear, and normal recurring maintenance wherein we recognize the expense when the maintenance work is completed, or over the repair period, if materially different. Our maintenance policy is determined by fleet when major maintenance is incurred. While we keep a record of expected maintenance events, the actual timing and costs of major engine maintenance expense are subject to variables such as estimated usage, government regulations and the level of unscheduled maintenance events and their actual costs. Accordingly, we cannot reliably quantify the costs or timing of future maintenance-related expenses for any significant period of time.Aircraft Leasing and Finance Determinations. We have generally funded aircraft acquisitions through a combination of operating leases and debt financing. Our determination to lease or finance the acquisition of aircraft may be influenced by a variety of factors, including the preferences of our major airline partners, the strength of our balance sheet and credit profile and those of our major airline partners, the length and terms of the available lease or financing alternatives, the applicable interest rates, and any lease return conditions. When possible, we prefer to finance aircraft through debt rather than operating leases, due to lower operating costs, extended depreciation period, opportunity for aircraft equity, absence of lease return conditions and greater flexibility in renewing the aircraft under our capacity purchase agreements with our major airline partners after paying off the principal balance. Subsequent to the initial acquisition of an aircraft, we may also refinance the aircraft or convert one form of financing to another (e.g., replacing an aircraft lease with debt financing). The purchase of leased aircraft allows us to lower our operating costs and avoid lease-related use restrictions and return conditions. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had 60 aircraft in our fleet under lease, including 42 E-175 aircraft owned by United and leased to us at nominal amounts. In order to determine the proper classification of our leased aircraft as either operating leases or capital leases, we must make certain estimates at the inception of the lease relating to the economic useful life and the fair value of an asset as well as select an appropriate discount rate to be used in discounting future lease payments. These estimates are utilized by management in making computations as required by existing accounting standards that determine whether the lease is classified as an operating lease or a capital lease. All of our aircraft leases have been classified as operating leases, which results in rental payments being charged to expense over the terms of the related leases. We are also subject to lease return provisions that require a minimum portion of eligible flight time for certain components remain when the aircraft is returned at the lease expiration. We estimate the cost of maintenance lease return obligations and accrue such costs over the remaining lease term when the expense is probable and can be reasonably estimated. Additionally, operating leases are not reflected on our consolidated balance sheet and accordingly, neither a lease asset nor an obligation for future lease payments is reflected in our consolidated balance sheets. See "Recent Accounting Pronouncements" in the notes to our consolidated financial statements below for a discussion of a new accounting standard that is likely to have an impact on our aircraft lease accounting beginning in our 2020 fiscal year.
See "Risk Factors" for a discussion of these factors and other risks.
Seasonality
Our results of operations for any interim period are not necessarily indicative of those for the entire year, since the airline industry is subject to seasonal fluctuations and general economic conditions. Our operations are somewhat favorably affected by increased utilization of our aircraft in the summer months and are unfavorably affected by increased fleet maintenance and by inclement weather during the winter months. 40
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Components of Our Results of Operations
The following discussion summarizes the key components of our consolidated statements of operations.
Operating Revenues
Our consolidated operating revenues consist primarily of contract revenue flight services as well as pass-through and other revenues.
Contract Revenue. Contract revenue consists of the fixed monthly amounts per aircraft received pursuant to our capacity purchase agreements with our major airline partners, along with the additional amounts received based on the number of flights and block hours flown. Contract revenues we receive from our major airline partners are paid and recognized by us on a weekly basis.
Pass-Through and Other. Pass-through and other revenue consists of passenger and hull insurance, aircraft property taxes, landing fees, catering and certain maintenance costs related to our E-175 aircraft.
Operating Expenses
Our operating expenses consist of the following items:
Flight Operations. Flight operations expense includes costs related to salaries, bonuses and benefits earned by our pilots, flight attendants, and dispatch personnel, as well as costs related to technical publications, lodging of our flight crews and pilot training expenses. Fuel. Fuel expense includes fuel and related fueling costs for flying we undertake outside of our capacity purchase agreements, including aircraft repositioning and maintenance. All aircraft fuel and related fueling costs for flying under our capacity purchase agreements were directly paid and supplied by our major airline partners. Accordingly, we do not record an expense or the related revenue for fuel supplied by American and United for flying under our capacity purchase agreements. Maintenance. Maintenance includes costs related to engine overhauls, airframe, landing gear and normal recurring maintenance, which includes pass-through maintenance costs related to our E-175 aircraft, as well as maintenance lease return obligations on our leased aircraft when the expense is probable and can be reasonably estimated. We record these expenses using the direct expense method of accounting, wherein the expense is recognized when the maintenance work is completed, or over the repair period, if materially different. As a result of using the direct expense method, the timing of maintenance expense reflected in the financial statements may vary significantly from period to period.
Aircraft Rent. Aircraft rent includes costs related to leased engines and aircraft.
Aircraft and Traffic Servicing. Aircraft and traffic servicing includes expenses related to our capacity purchase agreements, including aircraft cleaning, passenger disruption reimbursements, international navigation fees and wages of airport operations personnel, a portion of which are reimbursable by our major airline partners.
General and Administrative. General and administrative expense includes insurance and taxes, non-operational administrative employee wages and related expenses, building rents, real property leases, utilities, legal, audit and other administrative expenses. The majority of insurance and taxes are pass-through costs.
Depreciation and Amortization. Depreciation expense is a periodic non-cash charge primarily related to aircraft, engine and equipment depreciation. Amortization expense is a periodic non-cash charge related to our customer relationship intangible asset.
Other (Expense) Income, Net
Interest Expense. Interest expense is interest on our debt to finance purchases of aircraft, engines, equipment as well as debt financing costs amortization.
Interest Income. Interest income includes interest income on our cash and cash equivalent balances.
41
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Expense. Other expense includes expense derived from activities not classified in any other area of the consolidated statements of income, including write-offs of miscellaneous third-party fees.
Segment Reporting
Operating segments are defined as components of an enterprise about which separate financial information is available that is evaluated regularly by the chief operating decision maker in deciding how to allocate resources and in assessing operating performance. In consideration of Accounting Standards Codification ("ASC") 280, "Segment Reporting," we are not organized around specific services or geographic regions. We currently operate in one service line providing scheduled flying services in accordance with our capacity purchase agreements. While we operate under two separate capacity purchase agreements, we do not manage our business based on any performance measure at the individual contract level. Additionally, our chief operating decision maker uses condensed consolidated financial information to evaluate our performance, which is the same basis on which he communicates our results and performance to our Board of Directors. He bases all significant decisions regarding the allocation of our resources on a consolidated basis. Based on the information described above and in accordance with the applicable literature, management has concluded that we are organized and operated as one operating and reportable segment.
Results of Operations
Comparison of our Fiscal Years Ended
We had operating income of$121.1 million in our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to operating income of$72.6 million inSeptember 30, 2018 . In our 2019 fiscal year, we had net income of$47.6 million compared to net income of$33.3 million in our 2018 fiscal year. Our operating results for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 reflected an increase in contract revenue primarily related to the additional flying of our E-175, CRJ-900 and CRJ-700 fleets as a result of increased pilot staffing level. We also experienced a decrease in aircraft rent expense as a result of purchasing nine CRJ-900 aircraft inJune 2018 and ten CRJ-700 aircraft inJune 2019 that were previously leased under our GECAS Lease Facility. We also experienced a decrease in lease termination expense for ten CRJ-700 aircraft purchased inJune 2019 , compared to the lease termination expense associated with the purchase of nine CRJ-900 aircraft inJune 2018 , both previously leased under our GECAS Lease Facility. Operating Revenues Year Ended September 30, 2019 2018 Change Operating revenues ($ in thousands): Contract$ 682,834 $ 639,264 $ 43,570 6.8 % Pass-through and other 40,523 42,331 (1,808 ) (4.3 )% Total operating revenues$ 723,357 $ 681,595 $ 41,762 6.1 % Operating data: (1) Available seat miles-ASMs (thousands) 10,863,623 9,713,877 1,149,746 11.8 % Block hours 456,247 410,974 45,273 11.0 % Revenue passenger miles- RPMs (thousands) 8,587,223 7,699,065 888,158 11.5 % Average stage length (miles) 579 560 19 3.4 % Contract revenue per available seat mile-CRASM (in cents) ¢ 6.29 ¢ 6.58$ (0.29 ) (4.4 )% Passengers 14,664,441 13,556,774 1,107,667 8.2 %
(1) The definitions of certain terms related to the airline industry used in the
table can be found under "Glossary of Airline Terms' in Part II, Item 6 "Selected Financial Data" above. 42
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Total operating revenue increased by$41.8 million , or 6.1%, during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . Contract revenue increased by$43.6 million , or 6.8%, primarily due to an increase in flying with our E-175, CRJ-900 and CRJ-700 fleets, an increase in performance incentive pay, and a decrease in credits given to our major airline partners based on contractual utilization levels. Our block hours flown during our fiscal yearSeptember 30, 2019 increased 11.0%, compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , due to increased flying with our E-175, CRJ-900 and CRJ-700 fleets. Our pass-through and other revenue decreased during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 by$1.8 million , or 4.3%, primarily due to a reduction in pass-through maintenance costs related to our E-175 fleet. Operating Expenses Year Ended September 30, 2019 2018 Change Operating expenses ($ in thousands): Flight operations$ 210,879 $ 209,065 $ 1,814 0.9 % Fuel 588 498 90 18.1 % Maintenance 196,514 193,164 3,350 1.7 % Aircraft rent 52,206 68,892 (16,686 ) (24.2 )% Aircraft and traffic servicing 3,972 3,541 431 12.2 % General and administrative 50,527 53,647 (3,120 ) (5.8 )% Depreciation and amortization 77,994 65,031 12,963 19.9 % Lease termination 9,540 15,109 (5,569 ) (36.9 )% Total operating expenses$ 602,220 $ 608,947
Operating data: Available seat miles-ASMs (thousands) 10,863,623 9,713,877 1,149,746 11.8 % Block hours 456,247 410,974 45,273 11.0 % Average stage length (miles) 579 560 19 3.4 % Departures 246,634 227,978 18,656 8.2 % Flight Operations. Flight operations expense increased$1.8 million , or$0 .9%, to$210.9 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . The increase was primarily driven by an increase in pilot and flight attendant wages due to additional flying, offset by a decrease in pilot premium pay as our pilot staffing levels have improved. Fuel. Fuel expense increased$0.09 million , or 18.1%, to$0.6 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . The increase was primarily driven by an increased number of ferry flights for maintenance events and maintenance fuel in ourPhoenix hub. All fuel costs related to flying under our capacity purchase agreements during our fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2019 and 2018 were directly paid to suppliers by our major airline partners. Maintenance. Aircraft maintenance costs increased$3.4 million , or 1.7%, to$196.5 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . This increase was primarily driven by an increase in labor and other expense, component contracts, and rotable and expendable parts expense. This increase was partially offset by a decrease in engine and pass-through engine and C-Check expense. During our 2019 fiscal year,$6.0 million of engine overhaul expenses were reimbursable by our major airline partners. Total pass-through maintenance expenses reimbursed by our major airline partners decreased by$8.6 million during our fiscal 2019, compared to fiscal 2018. 43
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following table presents information regarding our aircraft maintenance
costs during our fiscal years ended
Year Ended September 30, 2019 2018 Change (in thousands) Engine overhaul$ 24,077 $ 38,869 $ (14,792 ) (38.1 )% Pass-through engine overhaul$ 5,960 $ 12,341 (6,381 ) (51.7 )% C-check$ 16,807 $ 14,048 2,759 19.6 % Pass-through C-check $ 396$ 7,456 (7,060 ) (94.7 )% Component contracts$ 37,572 $ 33,221 4,351 13.1 % Rotable and expendable parts$ 29,853 $ 23,989 5,864 24.4 % Other pass-through$ 12,885 $ 8,019 4,866 60.7 % Labor and other$ 68,964 $ 55,221 13,743 24.9 % Total$ 196,514 $ 193,164 $ 3,350 1.7 % Aircraft Rent. Aircraft rent expense decreased$16.7 million , or 24.2%, to$52.2 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . This decrease was primarily attributable to$16.6 million decrease in aircraft lease expense due to the purchase of nine CRJ-900 and ten CRJ-700 aircraft, previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, inJune 2018 andJune 2019 , respectively. Aircraft and Traffic Servicing. Aircraft and traffic servicing expense increased$0.4 million , or 12.2%, to$4.0 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . This increase was primarily due to an increase in interrupted trip expense and higher pass-through regulatory charges. For our fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2019 and 2018, 52.6% and 53.0%, respectively, of our aircraft and traffic servicing expenses were reimbursed by our major airline partners. General and Administrative. General and administrative expense decrease$3.1 million , or 5.8%, to$50.5 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . This decrease was primarily due to a decrease in amortization of our restricted stock compensation and slightly offset in pass- through property tax and passenger liability expense. Depreciation and Amortization. Depreciation and amortization expense increased$13.0 million , or 19.9%, to$78.0 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . This increase was primarily attributable to an increase in depreciation expense related to our purchase of spare engines and aircraft depreciation related to the purchase of the nine CRJ-900 and ten CRJ-700 aircraft, previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, inJune 2018 andJune 2019 respectively. Lease Termination. Lease termination expense decreased$5.6 million , or 36.9%, for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . The decrease is primarily driven by a lower lease termination expense for the ten CRJ-700 aircraft purchased inJune 2019 , compared to the lease termination expense associated the purchase of the nine CRJ-900 aircraft inJune 2018 , which were both under the GECAS Lease facility.
Other Expense
Other expense increased$1.0 million , or 1.8%, to$57.9 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . The increase is primarily due to a one-time extinguishment of debt expense of$3.6 million related to the repayment of our Spare Engine Facility. Interest expense decreased$1.2 million primarily due to a decrease in interest expense related to our Spare Engine Facility, CIT Revolving Credit Facility and EDC engine financing, which decrease was partially offset by an increase in interest expense due to the financing of nine CRJ-900 and ten CRJ-700 aircraft inJune 2018 andJune 2019 , respectively, which were previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility. Our expenses related to debt financing amortization decreased by$0.3 million is primarily due to the write-off of financing fees related to the repayment of our Spare Engine Facility. Additionally, interest income increased by$1.4 million in the twelve months endedSeptember 30, 2019 , compared to the same period in 2018. 44
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Income Taxes
In our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , our effective tax rate was 24.8% compared to (110.1%) in our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . Our tax rate can vary depending on changes in tax laws, adoption of accounting standards, the amount of income we earn in each state and the state tax rate applicable to such income, as well as any valuation allowance required on our state net operating losses.
We recorded an income tax provision of
The income tax provision for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 resulted in an effective tax rate of 25.0%, which differed from theU.S. federal statutory rate of 21%, primarily due to the impact of state taxes and permanent differences between financial statement and taxable income. In addition to the state effective tax rate impact, other state impacts include changes in the valuation allowance against state net operating losses, expired state attributes, and changes in state apportionment and statutory rates. The income tax provision for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 resulted in an effective tax rate of (110.1%), which differed from theU.S. federal statutory rate of 35% throughDecember 31, 2017 and 21% as ofJanuary 1, 2018 , primarily due to a re-measurement of our net deferred tax liability due to federal tax law changes and the adoption of Accounting Standards Update 2016-09. Other factors include changes in the valuation allowance against state net operating losses, expired state attributes and state apportionment and statutory rates. OnDecember 22, 2017 , the President signed the Tax Act into law. The Tax Act incorporated several new provisions that had an impact on our financial statements. Most notably, the Tax Act decreased the federal statutory rate to 21% for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 and subsequent fiscal years. The decrease in the federal statutory rate resulted in a net tax benefit in fiscal 2018 due to the re-measurement of our net deferred tax liability. The Company's net operating losses incurred in the fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 and in subsequent years may be used to offset up to 80% of taxable income in a given year and the Company's net operating losses incurred in fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 and in subsequent fiscal years are allowed to be carried indefinitely.
We continue to maintain a valuation allowance on a portion of our state net operating losses in jurisdictions with shortened carryforward periods or in jurisdictions where our operations have significantly decreased as compared to prior years in which the net operating losses were generated.
As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had aggregate federal and state net operating loss carryforwards of approximately$478.3 million and$228.3 million , which expire in 2027-2037 and 2020-2039, respectively, with approximately$0.9 million of state net operating loss carryforwards that expired in 2019.
See Note 12: "Income Taxes" in the notes to the audited consolidated financial statements included elsewhere in this Annual Report Form 10-K.
Comparison of our Fiscal Years Ended
We had operating income of$72.6 million in our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to operating income of$100.3 million in our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . In our 2018 fiscal year, we had net income of$33.3 million compared to net income of$32.8 million in our 2017 fiscal year. Our operating results for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 reflected an increase in contract revenue primarily related to the addition of 12 E-175 aircraft under our United Capacity Purchase Agreement, which was partially offset by reduced flying of our CRJ-900 and CRJ-700 fleet. We also experienced an increase in flight operations expense driven by an increase in pilot training and related expenses and an increase in premium pilot pay to incentivize pilots to fly additional routes until additional pilots complete their training.
Our maintenance expense decreased due to the timing of significant engine
overhaul events, which occurred less frequently during our fiscal year ended
We recorded two one-time non-cash adjustments in our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . The first adjustment was$15.1 million of lease termination expense related to our acquisition of nine CRJ-900 aircraft, which were previously leased under our GECAS Lease Facility. The second adjustment related to an increase in the value of our SARs associated with an increase in fair value of our common stock as well as a change in accounting methodology from the intrinsic value method to fair value method. These changes resulted in a general and administrative expense of$11.1 million . 45
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating Revenues Year Ended September 30, 2018 2017 Change Operating revenues ($ in thousands): Contract$ 639,264 $ 618,698 $ 20,566 3.3 % Pass-through and other$ 42,331 $ 24,878 17,453 70.2 % Total operating revenues$ 681,595 $ 643,576 $ 38,019 5.9 % Operating data: (1) Available seat miles-ASMs (miles in thousands) 9,713,877 9,471,911 241,966 2.6 % Block hours 410,974 395,083 15,891 4.0 %
Revenue passenger miles-RPMs (miles in
thousands) 7,699,065 7,392,688 306,377 4.1 % Average stage length (miles) 560 561 (1 ) (0.2 )% Contract revenue per available seat mile- CRASM (in cents) ¢ 6.58 ¢ 6.53 ¢ 0.05 0.8 % Passengers 13,556,774 13,005,844 550,930 4.2 %
(1) The definitions of certain terms related to the airline industry used in the
table can be found under "Glossary of Airline Terms' in Part II, Item 6 "Selected Financial Data" above. Total operating revenue increased by$38.0 million , or 5.9%, during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . Contract revenue increased by$20.6 million , or 3.3%, primarily due to an increase in flying with our expanded E-175 fleet and higher block hour compensation. Our block hours flown during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 increased 4.0%, compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 , due to increased flying on our E-175 fleet, which was partially offset by reduced flight schedules caused by increased pilot training times. Our pass-through and other revenue increased during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 by$17.5 million , or 70.2%, primarily due to pass-through maintenance costs related to our E-175 fleet Operating Expenses Year Ended September 30, 2018 2017 Change Operating expenses ($ in thousands): Flight operations$ 209,065 $ 155,516 $ 53,549 34.4 % Fuel $ 498$ 766 $ (268 ) (35.0 )% Maintenance$ 193,164 $ 210,729 $ (17,565 ) (8.3 )% Aircraft rent$ 68,892 $ 72,551 $ (3,659 ) (5.0 )% Aircraft and traffic servicing$ 3,541 $ 3,676 $ (135 ) (3.7 )% General and administrative$ 53,647 $ 38,996 $ 14,651 37.6 % Depreciation and amortization$ 65,031 $ 61,048 $ 3,983 6.5 % Lease Termination$ 15,109 $ -$ 15,109 100.0 % Total operating expenses$ 608,947 $ 543,282 $ 65,665 12.1 % Operating data: Available seat miles-ASMs (miles in thousands) 9,713,877 9,471,911 241,966 2.6 % Block hours 410,974 395,083 15,891 4.0 % Average stage length (miles) 560 561 (1 ) (0.2 )% Departures 227,978 221,990 5,988 2.7 % Flight Operations. Flight operations expense increased$53.5 million , or 34.4%, to$209.1 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This increase was primarily driven by an increase in pilot training related expenses, an increase in premium pilot pay to incentivize pilots to fly additional routes until additional pilots complete their training and additional pilot and flight attendant wages due to the additional flying, as well as our new collective bargaining agreements. 46 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Fuel. Fuel expense decreased$0.3 million , or 35.0%, to$0.5 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . The decrease was primarily driven by a reduced number of ferry flights for maintenance events and maintenance fuel in ourPhoenix hub. All fuel costs related to flying under our capacity purchase agreements during our fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2018 and 2017 were directly paid to suppliers by our major airline partners. Maintenance. Aircraft maintenance costs decreased$17.6 million , or 8.3%, to$193.2 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This decrease was primarily driven by a decrease in engine overhaul expense, rotable and expendable parts expense and labor and other expense. This decrease was partially offset by an increase in component contracts expense and other pass-through expense. During our 2018 fiscal year,$12.3 million of engine overhaul expenses were reimbursable by our major airline partners. Total pass-through maintenance expenses reimbursed by our major airline partners increased by$16.7 million during our fiscal 2018, compared to fiscal 2017.
The following table presents information regarding our aircraft maintenance
costs during our fiscal years ended
Year Ended September 30, 2018 2017 Change (in thousands) Engine overhaul$ 38,869 $ 63,719 $ (24,850 ) (39.0 )% Pass-through engine overhaul 12,341 270$ 12,071 4470.7 % C-check 14,048 17,755$ (3,707 ) (20.9 )% Pass-through C-check 7,456 4,889$ 2,567 52.5 % Component contracts 33,221 31,671$ 1,550 4.9 % Rotable and expendable parts 23,989 26,098$ (2,109 ) (8.1 )% Other pass-through 8,019 6,003$ 2,016 33.6 % Labor and other 55,221 60,324 (5,103 ) (8.5 )% Total$ 193,164 $ 210,729 $ (17,565 ) (8.3 )% Aircraft Rent. Aircraft rent expense decreased$3.7 million , or 5.0%, to$68.9 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This decrease was attributable to a$0.3 million increase in engine rent and a$3.9 million decrease in aircraft lease expense due to purchasing nine CRJ-900 aircraft, previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, inJune 2018 . Aircraft and Traffic Servicing. Aircraft and traffic servicing expense decreased$0.1 million , or 3.7%, to$3.5 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This decrease was primarily due to a decrease in interrupted trip expense which was partially offset by higher pass-through regulatory charges. For our fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2018 and 2017, 53.0% and 46.5%, respectively, of our aircraft and traffic servicing expenses were reimbursed by our major airline partners. General and Administrative. General and administrative expense increased$14.7 million , or 37.6%, to$53.6 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This increase was primarily related to a one-time, non-cash$11.1 million expense related to an increase in the value of our SARs associated with an increase in fair value of our common stock as well as a change in accounting methodology from the intrinsic value method to fair value method. The remainder of the variance was due to an increase in audit fees, property taxes and fees associated with restructuring the RASPRO Lease Facility. Depreciation and Amortization. Depreciation and amortization expense increased$4.0 million , or 6.5%, to$65.0 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This increase was primarily attributable to an increase in depreciation expense related to our purchase of spare engines and aircraft depreciation related to the purchase of the nine CRJ-900 aircraft, previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, inJune 2018 . Lease Termination. Lease termination expense increased$15.1 million , or 100%, for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This increase was related to our acquisition of nine CRJ-900 aircraft, previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, inJune 2018 . 47
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other Expense
Other expense increased$10.2 million , or 22.0%, to$56.8 million for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , compared to our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . This increase was primarily due to an increase in interest expense of$8.7 million related to the financing of 23 spare engines, the financing of nine CRJ-900 aircraft, previously leased under our GECAS Lease Facility, inJune 2018 , the refinancing of fifteen CRJ-900 aircraft, our line of credit with CIT, a deferment of certain payments under the RASPRO Lease Facility, engine overhaul financing and higher London InterBank Offered Rate ("LIBOR") rates. Our expenses related to debt financing amortization were also higher in our fiscal 2018 by$1.9 million , which was attributable to legal and commitment fees incurred in connection with our aircraft and engine financing, as well as aircraft debt refinancing
Income Taxes
In our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , our effective tax rate was (110.1%) compared to 38.9% in our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 . Our tax rate can vary depending on changes in tax laws, adoption of accounting standards, the amount of income we earn in each state and the state tax rate applicable to such income, as well as any valuation allowance required on our state net operating losses.
We recorded an income tax provision of
The income tax provision for the year endedSeptember 30, 2018 results in an effective tax rate of (110.1%), which differed from theU.S. federal statutory rate of 35% throughDecember 31, 2017 and 21% as ofJanuary 1, 2018 primarily due to a re-measurement of our net deferred tax liability due to federal tax law changes and the adoption of Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2016-09. Other factors include changes in the valuation allowance against state net operating losses, expired state attributes and state apportionment and statutory rates. The income tax provision for the year endedSeptember 30, 2017 results in an effective tax rate of 38.9%, which differed from theU.S. federal statutory rate of 35% primarily due to state taxes, changes in the valuation allowance against state net operating losses, expired state attributes, and the benefit resulting from changes in state apportionment and statutory rates. OnDecember 22, 2017 , the President signed into law the legislation colloquially known as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (the "Tax Act"). The Tax Act incorporates several new provisions that will have an impact on our financial statements. Most notably, the Tax Act decreased the federal statutory rate to 24.5% for the year endingSeptember 30, 2018 , and 21% for the years endingSeptember 30, 2019 and forward. The decrease in federal statutory rate resulted in a net tax benefit due to the re-measurement of our net deferred tax liability. The change in our future effective tax rate is not anticipated to have an effect on our taxes until all of ourU.S. federal net operating losses and credits have been utilized. Additional provisions of the Tax Act that may impact our financial statements include 100% expensing of qualified property placed in service afterSeptember 27, 2017 and beforeJanuary 1, 2023 , refundable minimum tax credits over a four year period, net interest expense deductions limited to 30% of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization through 2021 and of earnings before interest and taxes thereafter, and net operating losses incurred in tax years beginning afterDecember 31, 2017 are only allowed to offset up to 80% of a taxpayer's taxable income. These net operating losses are allowed to be carried forward indefinitely.
We continue to maintain a valuation allowance on a portion of our state net operating losses in jurisdictions with shortened carryforward periods or in jurisdictions where our operations have significantly decreased as compared to prior years in which the net operating losses were generated.
As ofSeptember 30, 2018 , we had aggregate federal and state net operating loss carryforwards of approximately$415.1 million and$199.5 million , which expire in 2027-2037 and 2019-2038, respectively, with approximately$20.1 million of state net operating loss carryforwards that expired in 2018.
See Note 11: "Income Taxes" in the notes to the audited consolidated financial statements included elsewhere in this Annual Report of Form 10-K.
48
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cautionary Statement Regarding Non-GAAP Measures
We present Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR in this Annual Report on Form 10-K, which are not recognized financial measures under accounting principles generally accepted inthe United States of America ("GAAP"), as supplemental disclosures because our senior management believes that they are well recognized valuation metrics in the airline industry that are frequently used by companies, investors, securities analysts and other interested parties in comparing companies in our industry.
Adjusted EBITDA. We define Adjusted EBITDA as net income or loss before interest, income taxes, depreciation and amortization, adjusted for the impact of revaluation of liability awards, lease termination costs, loss on extinguishment of debt and write-off of associated financing fees.
Adjusted EBITDAR. We define Adjusted EBITDAR as net income or loss before interest, income taxes, depreciation and amortization and aircraft rent, adjusted for the impact of revaluation of liability awards, lease termination costs, loss on extinguishment of debt and write-off of associated financing fees.
You are encouraged to evaluate these adjustments and the reasons we consider them appropriate for supplemental analysis. In evaluating Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR, you should be aware that in the future we may incur expenses that are the same as or similar to some of the adjustments in our presentation of Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR. Our presentation of Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR should not be construed as an inference that our future results will be unaffected by unusual or non-recurring items. There can be no assurance that we will not modify the presentation of Adjusted EBITDA or Adjusted EBITDAR and any such modification may be material. Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR have limitations as analytical tools. Some of the limitations applicable to these measures include: (i) Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR do not reflect the impact of certain cash charges resulting from matters we consider not to be indicative of our ongoing operations; (ii) Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR do not reflect our cash expenditures, or future requirements, for capital expenditures or contractual commitments; (iii) Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR do not reflect changes in, or cash requirements for, our working capital needs; (iv) Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR do not reflect the interest expense, or the cash requirements necessary to service interest or principal payments, on our debts; (v) although depreciation and amortization are non-cash charges, the assets being depreciated and amortized will often have to be replaced in the future; and (vi) Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR do not reflect any cash requirements for such replacements and other companies in our industry may calculate Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR differently than we do, limiting its usefulness as a comparative measure. Because of these limitations, Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for performance measures calculated in accordance with GAAP. In addition, Adjusted EBITDAR should not be viewed as a measure of overall performance because it excludes aircraft rent, which is a normal, recurring cash operating expense that is necessary to operate our business. For the foregoing reasons, each of Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR has significant limitations which affect its use as an indicator of our profitability. Accordingly, you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on this information. 49
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR
The following table presents a reconciliation of net (loss) income to estimated Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDAR for the period presented:
Year Ended September 30, 2019 2018 2017 (in thousands) Reconciliation: Net income$ 47,580 $ 33,255 $ 32,828
Income tax (benefit) expense 15,706 (17,426 ) 20,874
Income before taxes$ 63,286 $ 15,829 $
53,702
Adjustments(1)(2)(3) 13,156 27,165
-
Adjusted income before taxes 76,442 42,994 53,702 Interest expense 55,717 56,867 46,110 Interest income (1,501 ) (114 ) (32 ) Depreciation and amortization 77,994 65,031 61,048 Adjusted EBITDA 208,652 164,778 160,828 Aircraft rent 52,206 68,892 72,551 Adjusted EBITDAR 260,858 233,670 233,379
(1) Our financial results reflect an increase in accrued compensation of
approximately
associated with an increase in fair value of our common stock as well as a
change in accounting methodology from the intrinsic value method to the fair
value method. These changes resulted in a general and administrative expense
of approximately
million to retained earnings as a result of the change in accounting
methodology for the twelve months ended
(2) Our financial results include lease termination expense of
respectively, related to our acquisition of ten CRJ-700 and nine CRJ-900
aircraft, which were previously leased under our GECAS Lease Facility.
(3) Our financial results reflect loss on extinguishment of debt of
related to repayment of the Company's Spare Engine Facility for the twelve
months ended
of financing fees. We also had
during our twelve months ended
Liquidity and Capital Resources
Sources and Uses of Cash
We require cash to fund our operating expenses and working capital requirements, including outlays for capital expenditures, aircraft pre-delivery payments, maintenance, aircraft rent and to pay debt service obligations, including principal and interest payments. Our cash needs vary from period to period primarily based on the timing and costs of significant maintenance events. Our principal sources of liquidity are cash on hand, cash generated from operations and funds from external borrowings. In the near term, we expect to fund our primary cash requirements through cash generated from operations and cash and cash equivalents on hand. We also have the ability to utilize the CIT Revolving Credit Facility, pursuant to which the lenders named therein (the "CIT Lenders") have committed to lend toMesa Airlines and MAG-AIM revolving loans in the aggregate principal amount of up to$35.0 million . This facility was paid down with proceeds from our IPO onAugust 14, 2018 but remains available until the facility matures onAugust 12, 2022 .
We believe that the key factors that could affect our internal and external sources of cash include:
? Factors that affect our results of operations and cash flows, including the
impact on our business and operations as a result of changes in demand for
our services, competitive pricing pressures, and our ability to achieve
further reductions in operating expenses; and
? Factors that affect our access to bank financing and the debt and equity
capital markets that could impair our ability to obtain needed financing on
acceptable terms or to respond to business opportunities and developments as
they arise, including interest rate fluctuations, macroeconomic conditions,
sudden reductions in the general availability of lending from banks or the
related increase in cost to obtain bank financing, and our ability to
maintain compliance with covenants under our debt agreements in effect from
time to time. 50
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Our ability to service our long-term debt obligations, including our equipment notes, to remain in compliance with the various covenants contained in our debt agreements and to fund working capital, capital expenditures and business development efforts will depend on our ability to generate cash from operating activities, which is subject to, among other things, our future operating performance, as well as to other factors, some of which may be beyond our control. If we fail to generate sufficient cash from operations, we may need to raise additional equity or borrow additional funds to achieve our longer-term objectives. There can be no assurance that such equity or borrowings will be available or, if available, will be at rates or prices acceptable to us. We believe that cash flow from operating activities coupled with existing cash and cash equivalents, short-term investments and existing credit facilities will be adequate to fund our operating and capital needs, as well as enable us to maintain compliance with our various debt agreements, through at least the next 12 months. To the extent that results or events differ from our financial projections or business plans, our liquidity may be adversely impacted. Prior to our IPO, our operations had been financed primarily by cash flow from operating activities and funds from external borrowings. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$68.9 million in cash and cash equivalents and marketable securities. In connection with our IPO, we issued and sold an aggregate of 9,630,000 shares of common stock as well as 723,985 shares of common stock from the exercise of the over-allotment option granted to the underwriters, which was exercised onSeptember 11, 2018 at a price to the public of$12.00 per share. We received proceeds of$111.7 million , net of underwriting discounts and commissions and offering costs. During the ordinary course of business, we evaluate our cash requirements and, if necessary, adjust operating and capital expenditures to reflect the current market conditions and our projected demand. Our capital expenditures are primarily directed toward our aircraft fleet and flight equipment. During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , we paid$125.4 million in capital expenditures primarily related to the purchase of ten CRJ-700 aircraft, which were previously leased, and eight spare engines. Our capital expenditures, net of purchases of rotable spare parts and aircraft and spare engine financing, have historically been approximately 1.5% to 2.5% of annual revenues, and we expect to continue to incur capital expenditures to support our business activities. Future capital expenditures may be impacted by events and transactions that are not currently forecasted. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , our principal sources of liquidity were cash and cash equivalents and marketable securities of$68.9 million . In addition, we had restricted cash of$3.6 million as ofSeptember 30, 2019 . Restricted cash includes certificates of deposit that secure letters of credit issued for particular airport authorities as required in certain lease agreements. Furthermore, as ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we also had$750.5 million in secured indebtedness incurred in connection with our financing of 84 total aircraft. Our primary uses of liquidity are capital expenditures and debt repayments. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$165.9 million of short-term debt, excluding capital leases, and$677.4 million of long-term debt excluding capital leases. Sources of cash for our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 were primarily cash flows from operations of$151.7 million . The positive cash flow from operations was driven by receipts from performance under our capacity purchase agreements.
Restricted Cash
As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$3.6 million in restricted cash. We have an agreement with a financial institution for a$6.0 million letter of credit facility and to issue letters of credit for landing fees, worker's compensation insurance and other business needs. Pursuant to the agreement,$3.6 million of outstanding letters of credit are required to be collateralized by amounts on deposit. 51
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cash Flows
The following table presents information regarding our cash flows for each of
our fiscal years ended
Year Ended September 30, 2019 2018 2017 (in thousands)
Net cash provided by operating activities
(104,842 ) (138,563 ) (84,076 ) Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities (81,467 ) 66,411 28,497 Net increase (decrease) in cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash (34,633 ) 46,787 19,148 Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at beginning of period 107,134 60,347 41,199 Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at end of period$ 72,501 $ 107,134 $ 60,347
Net Cash Flow Provided by Operating Activities
During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , our cash flow provided by operating activities of$151.7 million reflected our growth and execution of our strategic initiatives. We had net income of$47.6 million adjusted for the following significant non-cash items: depreciation and amortization of$78.0 million , amortization of stock-based compensation of$5.5 million , deferred income taxes of$15.5 million , amortization of unfavorable lease liabilities and deferred credits of$(10.8) million , amortization of debt financing costs and accretion of interest on non-interest bearing subordinated notes of$4.2 million , loss on extinguishment of debt of$3.6 million and lease termination expense of$9.5 million . We had net change of$(2.1) million within other net operating assets and liabilities largely driven by expendable parts and accounts payable during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 . During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , our cash flow provided by operating activities of$118.9 million reflected our growth and execution of our strategic initiatives. We had net income of$33.3 million adjusted for the following significant non-cash items: depreciation and amortization of$65.0 million , amortization of stock-based compensation of$12.9 million , deferred income taxes of$(17.9) million , amortization of unfavorable lease liabilities and deferred credits of$(11.0) million , amortization of debt financing costs and accretion of interest on non-interest bearing subordinated notes of$4.6 million and lease termination expense of$15.1 million . We had a net change of$16.4 million within other net operating assets and liabilities largely driven by accrued compensation liability and other accrued liabilities during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 . During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 , our cash flow provided by operating activities of$74.7 million reflects our growth and execution of our strategic initiatives. We had net income of$32.8 million adjusted for the following significant non-cash items: depreciation and amortization of$61.0 million , amortization of stock-based compensation of$1.3 million , deferred income taxes of$20.5 million , amortization of unfavorable lease liabilities and deferred credits of$(10.6) million and amortization of debt financing costs and accretion of interest on non-interest bearing subordinated notes of$2.7 million . We had net outflows of$33.9 million within other net operating assets and liabilities largely driven by aircraft lease payments during our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017
Net Cash Flows Used in Investing Activities
During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , our net cash flow used in investing activities was$(104.8) million . We invested$125.4 million in ten aircraft and seven spare engines and aircraft improvements, offset by$20.1 million from net sales of investment securities, and$0.4 million in equipment deposits.
During our fiscal year ended
During our fiscal year ended
52
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Net Cash Flows Provided by (Used in) Financing Activities
During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2019 , our net cash flow used in financing activities was$(81.5) million . We received$171.7 million in proceeds from long-term debt primarily related to purchasing ten aircraft, and spare aircraft engine and aircraft engine kit financing. We made$244.1 million of principal repayments on long-term debt during the period. We incurred$5.7 million of costs related to debt financing,$1.7 million in debt prepayment costs, and$1.9 million of costs related to the repurchase of shares of our common stock. During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2018 , our net cash flow provided by financing activities was$66.4 million . We received$187.7 million in proceeds from long-term debt primarily related to purchasing nine aircraft, refinancing debt on aircraft, as well as spare aircraft engine and aircraft engine kit financing. We made$222.2 million of principal repayments on long-term debt during the period. We received$111.7 million , net of issuance costs, in proceeds from the issuance of our common stock. We also incurred$5.9 million of costs related to debt financing and$5.0 million of costs related to the repurchase of shares of our common stock. During our fiscal year endedSeptember 30, 2017 , our net cash flow provided by financing activities was$28.5 million . We received$185.9 million in proceeds from long-term debt primarily related to spare aircraft engine and aircraft engine kit financing. We made$153.0 million of principal repayments on long-term debt and incurred$3.4 million of costs related to debt financing and$1.0 million of costs related to the repurchase of shares of our common stock during the period.
Commitments and Contractual Obligations
As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$1,171.7 million of long-term debt (including principal and projected interest obligations) and capital and operating lease obligations (including current maturities). This amount consisted of$894.3 million in notes payable related to owned aircraft used in continuing operations,$111.1 million in notes payable related to spare engines and engine kits,$10.1 million in capital leases and$0.8 million outstanding under our working capital line of credit. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we also had$155.4 million of operating lease obligations primarily related to aircraft flown under our capacity purchase agreements. Our long-term debt obligations set forth below include an aggregate of$158.2 million in projected interest costs through our fiscal 2028. The following table sets forth our cash obligations as ofSeptember 30, 2019 : Payment Due for Year Ending September 30, (in thousands) Total 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Thereafter Aircraft notes$ 894,309 $ 175,908 $ 169,051 $ 151,939 $ 95,588 $ 76,891 $ 224,932 Engine notes 111,123 32,350 25,146 23,715 22,954 6,958 -
Operating lease obligations 155,354 49,663 46,322
31,090 13,727 13,184 1,368 Working capital line of credit 798 266 266 266 - - - Capital Leases 10,130 2,540 2,640 2,640 2,310 - - Total$ 1,171,714 $ 260,727 $ 243,425 $ 209,650 $ 134,579 $ 97,033 $ 226,300
As of
Operating Leases
We have significant long-term lease obligations primarily relating to our aircraft fleet. The leases are classified as operating leases and are therefore excluded from our consolidated balance sheets. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had 18 aircraft on lease (excluding aircraft leased from United) with remaining lease terms up to 4.5 years. Future minimum lease payments due under all long-term operating leases were approximately$155.4 million as ofSeptember 30, 2019 . RASPRO Lease Facility. OnSeptember 23, 2005 ,Mesa Airlines , as lessee, entered into the RASPRO Lease Facility, with RASPRO as lessor, for 15 of our CRJ-900 aircraft. The obligations under the RASPRO Lease Facility are guaranteed by us, and basic rent is paid quarterly on each aircraft. On each ofMarch 10, 2014 ,June 5, 2014 andDecember 8, 2017 , the RASPRO Lease Facility was amended to defer certain payments of basic rent (the "Deferred Amounts"). Until the principal of and accrued interest on the Deferred Amounts are paid in full, (i) we andMesa Airlines are prohibited from paying any dividends to holders of our common stock, (ii) we are prohibited from repurchasing any of our warrants or other equity interests, (iii)Mesa Airlines must maintain available a minimum of$10 million of cash, cash equivalents and availability under lines of credit, (iv)Mesa Airlines must provide RASPRO with periodic monthly, quarterly and annual reports containing certain financial information and forecasted engine repair costs and (v) we must maintain a minimum debt-to-assets ratio. 53
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pursuant to the
GECAS Lease Facility. OnMay 27, 2014 ,Mesa Airlines , as lessee, entered into an aircraft lease facility withWells Fargo Bank Northwest, National Association , as owner trustee and lessor, governing the lease of 19 of our CRJ-700 and CRJ-900 aircraft. The obligations under the GECAS Lease Facility are guaranteed by us, and basic rent is paid monthly on each aircraft. In consideration for the lease, we issued a warrant to purchase 250,000 shares of our common stock toGE Capital Aviation Services LLC (the "GE Warrant"), which we mutually agreed to terminate in connection with our purchase of nine CRJ-900 aircraft inJune 2018 that we previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility. The GECAS Lease Facility requiresMesa Airlines and us to maintain a balance of unrestricted cash of not less than$10 million and prohibited us from paying dividends to holders of our common stock prior toSeptember 30, 2019 without the prior written consent of the GECAS Lease Facility parties. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , all the aircraft under the GECAS Lease Facility have been purchased, therefore, the covenants are no longer in effect. As more fully described under "Aircraft Notes" below, onJune 26, 2018 , we purchased nine CRJ-900 aircraft, which were previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, for$76.5 million and terminated the GE Warrant. OnJune 14, 2019 , we purchased ten CRJ-700 aircraft, which were previously leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, for$70.0 million .
Capital Leases
OnFebruary 7, 2018 ,Mesa Airlines , as lessee, entered into two agreements for the lease of two spare aircraft engines (the "Engine Leases"). Basic rent on the engines is paid monthly and at the end of the lease term. InNovember 2022 ,Mesa Airlines will have the option to purchase the engines for$935,230 . The Engine Leases are reflected as debt obligations of$8.5 million on our balance sheet as ofSeptember 30, 2019 . The Engine Leases set forth specific redelivery requirements and conditions, but do not contain operational or financial covenants.
Working Capital Line of Credit
InAugust 2016 , we, as guarantor, our wholly owned subsidiaries,Mesa Airlines and MAG-AIM, as borrowers, CIT, as administrative agent, and the lenders party thereto, entered into the CIT Revolving Credit Facility, pursuant to which the CIT Lenders committed to lend toMesa Airlines and MAG-AIM revolving loans in the aggregate principal amount of up to$35.0 million . The borrowers' and guarantor's obligations under the CIT Revolving Credit Facility are secured primarily by a first priority lien on certain engines, spare parts and related collateral, including engine warranties and proceeds of the foregoing. The CIT Revolving Credit Facility contains affirmative, negative and financial covenants that are typical in the industry for similar financings, including, but not limited to, covenants that, subject to exceptions described in the CIT Revolving Credit Facility, restrict our ability and the ability ofMesa Airlines and MAG-AIM and their subsidiaries to: (i) enter into, create, incur, assume or suffer to exist any liens; (ii) merge, dissolve, liquidate, consolidate or sell or transfer substantially all of its assets; (iii) sell assets; (iv) enter into transactions with affiliates; (v) amend certain material agreements and organizational documents; (vi) make consolidated unfinanced capital expenditures; or (viii) maintain a consolidated interest and rental coverage ratio above the amount specified in the CIT Revolving Credit Facility. OnApril 27, 2018 , we entered into an amendment to the CIT Revolving Credit Facility to lower the consolidated interest and rental coverage ratio through the end of the term of the agreement. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we were in compliance with the financial covenants under the CIT Revolving Credit Facility. The CIT Revolving Credit Facility also includes customary events of defaults, including but not limited to: (i) payment defaults; (ii) breach of covenants; (iii) breach of representations and warranties; (iv) cross-defaults; (v) certain bankruptcy-related defaults; (vi) change of control; and (vii) revocation of instructions with respect to certain controlled accounts. OnAugust 14, 2018 , we paid down the outstanding balance on the CIT Revolving Credit Facility of$25.7 million . The CIT Revolving Credit Facility matured onAugust 12, 2019 and was renewed for an additional three years. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , there were no borrowings outstanding under this facility. Funds available under the CIT Revolving Credit Facility are subject to certain administrative and commitment fees, and funds under the facility bear interest at LIBOR plus a margin of 3.75%. 54
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Engine Notes
Spare Engine Facility. InDecember 2016 ,Mesa Airlines , as borrower,Obsidian Agency Services, Inc. , as security trustee,Cortland Capital Market Services LLC , as administrative agent, and the lenders party thereto (the "Engine Financing Lenders") entered into a credit agreement (the "Spare Engine Facility") pursuant to which the Engine Financing Lenders committed to lend toMesa Airlines term loans in the aggregate principal amount of up to approximately$111.1 million . InFebruary 2018 , the parties amended the Spare Engine Facility to increase the commitment of the Engine Financing Lenders by an additional aggregate principal amount of up to approximately$4.1 million .Mesa Airlines' obligations under the Spare Engine Facility are secured primarily by a first priority lien on certain engines acquired with the proceeds of the Spare Engine Facility and related collateral, including engine warranties and proceeds of the foregoing. The Spare Engine Facility contains affirmative and negative covenants that are typical in the industry for similar financings, including, but not limited to, covenants that, subject to exceptions described in the Spare Engine Facility, restrict the ability ofMesa Airlines to: (i) enter into, create, incur, assume or suffer to exist any liens; and (ii) merge, dissolve, liquidate, consolidate or sell or transfer substantially all of its assets. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , the Spare Engine Facility was repaid, resulting in the termination of all such covenants. Term Loan. OnJanuary 28, 2019 , the Company entered into a Term Loan Agreement (the "Term Loan") pursuant to which the lenders thereunder committed to lend to the Company term loans in the aggregate principal amount of$91.2 million . Borrowings under the Term Loan bear interest at LIBOR plus 3.10%. This interest rate is significantly lower than the interest rate under the Company's Spare Engine Facility (LIBOR plus 7.25%), which the Term Loan refinanced and replaced. The Term Loan has a term of five years, with principal and interest payments due monthly over the term of the loan in accordance with an amortization schedule. The Company recorded a loss on extinguishment of debt of$3.6 million , due to a$1.9 million write-off of financing fees and$1.7 million in prepayment penalties, in connection with the repayment of the Spare Engine Facility. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 ,$80.2 million of borrowings were outstanding under this facility. The Company financed certain engines onSeptember 27, 2019 for$8.0 million . The debt bears interest at the monthly LIBOR plus 5.25% (7.27% atSeptember 30, 2019 ) and requires monthly principal and interest payments. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 ,$8.0 million of borrowings were outstanding under these notes. EDC Credit Facilities. InAugust 2015 ,Mesa Airlines , as borrower, and EDC, as lender entered into a credit agreement (the "EDC 2015 Credit Facility") pursuant to which EDC committed to purchase notes fromMesa Airlines from time to time in the aggregate principal amount of up to$11.0 million . The borrower's obligations under the EDC 2015 Credit Facility are unsecured and guaranteed by us. The EDC 2015 Credit Facility contains affirmative and negative covenants that are typical in the industry for similar financings, including, but not limited to, covenants that, subject to exceptions described in the EDC 2015 Credit Facility, restrict our ability to: (i) merge, dissolve, liquidate, consolidate or sell or transfer substantially all of its assets; or (ii) sell assets. The EDC 2015 Credit Facility also includes customary events of defaults, including, but not limited to: (i) payment defaults; (ii) breach of covenants; (iii) breach of representations and warranties; (iv) cross-defaults; (v) certain bankruptcy-related defaults ofMesa Airlines or of specified carriers; and (vi) termination or material adverse change in the terms of any code sharing agreement. Each note matures on the date that is five years after such note was issued. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 ,$2.3 million of borrowings were outstanding under this facility. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we were in compliance with the covenants described above. Funds drawn under the EDC 2015 Credit Facility are subject to certain arrangement and commitment fees, and funds drawn under the facility bear interest at (i) LIBOR plus a margin of 2.66% plus a margin benchmark of 0.41% or (ii) a fixed amount based on a swap rate of floating rate debt to fixed rate debt, plus a margin of 2.66% and plus a margin benchmark of 0.58%. Installment payments must be made on each note issued under this facility. InJanuary 2016 ,Mesa Airlines , as borrower, and EDC, as lender, entered into a credit agreement (the "EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility") pursuant to which EDC committed to purchase notes fromMesa Airlines from time to time in the aggregate principal amount of up to$37.0 million . The borrower's obligations under the EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility are secured by the underlying equipment and guaranteed by us. The EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility contains affirmative and negative covenants that are typical in the industry for similar financings, including, but not limited to, covenants that, subject to exceptions described in the EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility, restrict our ability to: (i) merge, dissolve, liquidate, consolidate or sell or transfer substantially all of our assets; or (ii) sell assets. The EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility also contains a financial covenant that requires us to maintain a fixed charge coverage ratio at the end of each fiscal quarter above the amount specified in the agreement. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we were in compliance with these covenants. 55 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility also includes customary events of default, including, but not limited to: (i) payment defaults; (ii) breach of covenants; (iii) breach of representations and warranties; (iv) cross-defaults; (v) certain bankruptcy-related defaults ofMesa Airlines or of specified carriers; (vi) termination or material adverse change in the terms of any code sharing agreement; and (vii) breach or termination of our agreement with StandardAero. Each note matures on the date that is three to four years after such note was issued. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , this debt has been repaid. Funds drawn under the EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility are subject to certain arrangement and commitment fees, and funds drawn under the facility bear interest at (i) LIBOR plus a margin of, initially, 2.49% plus a margin benchmark of 0.47% or (ii) a fixed amount based on a swap rate of floating rate debt to fixed rate debt plus a margin of, initially, 2.49% plus a margin benchmark of 0.68%. Installment payments must be made on each note issued under this facility. OnApril 30, 2018 ,Mesa Airlines and EDC amended the EDCJanuary 2016 Credit Facility to, among other things, lower the required fixed charge ratio covenant through the end of the term of the agreement and provide for mandatory principal prepayments of$1 million per quarter over the next five fiscal quarters, beginning onSeptember 30, 2018 . InJune 2016 ,Mesa Airlines , as borrower, and EDC, as lender, entered into a credit agreement (the "EDCJune 2016 Credit Facility") pursuant to which EDC committed to purchase notes fromMesa Airlines from time to time in the aggregate principal amount of up to$25.0 million . The borrower's obligations under the EDCJune 2016 Credit Facility are unsecured and guaranteed by us. The EDCJune 2016 Credit Facility contains affirmative and negative covenants and events of default that are typical in the industry for similar financings, including the requirement to maintain a consolidated interest and rental coverage ratio. Each note matures on the date that is two years after such note was issued. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , this debt has been repaid. Funds drawn under the EDCJune 2016 Credit Facility are subject to certain arrangement and commitment fees, and funds drawn under the facility bear interest at (i) LIBOR plus a margin of 2.81% plus a margin benchmark of 0.49% or (ii) a fixed amount based on a swap rate of floating rate debt to fixed rate debt, plus a margin of 2.81%, plus a margin benchmark of 0.71%. Installment payments must be made on each note issued under this facility. Midfirst Engine Facility. InMay 2015 ,Mesa Airlines , as borrower, andMidFirst Bank , as lender, entered into a business loan agreement and accompanying promissory note (the "MidFirst Credit Facility") pursuant to whichMidFirst Bank committed to lend toMesa Airlines the principal amount of$8.5 million . The borrower's obligations under the MidFirst Credit Facility are guaranteed by us and are secured primarily by a lien on certain spare engines acquired with the proceeds of the MidFirst Credit Facility and related collateral. The MidFirst Credit Facility contains affirmative and negative covenants and events of default that are typical in the industry for similar financings. The promissory note matures onSeptember 21, 2020 . As ofSeptember 30, 2019 ,$1.7 million of borrowings were outstanding under this facility. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we were in compliance with the covenants described above.
Funds drawn under the MidFirst Credit Facility bear interest at the rate of 5.163% per annum. Installment payments of principal must be made on the promissory note issued under this facility.
Aircraft Notes
As of
? In fiscal year 2007, we permanently financed three CRJ-900 and three CRJ-700
aircraft for
plus 2.25% (4.27% at
interest payments. As of
under these notes. ? In fiscal year 2015, we permanently financed 10 CRJ-900 aircraft for
ranging from 1.95% to 7.25% (3.97% to 9.27% at
requires monthly principal and interest payments. As of
we had
? In fiscal year 2015, we permanently financed eight CRJ-900 aircraft with
principal and interest payments. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$60.8 million outstanding under these notes.
? In fiscal year 2016, we financed seven CRJ-900 aircraft with
in debt. The senior notes payable of
LIBOR plus 2.71% (4.73% at
and interest payments. The subordinated notes payable are noninterest-bearing
and become payable in full on the last day of the term of the notes. We have
imputed an interest rate of 6.25% on the subordinated notes payable and recorded a related discount of$8.1 million , which is being accreted to
interest expense over the term of the notes. As of
$110.9 million outstanding under these notes. 56
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
? In fiscal year 2017, we financed 10 E-175 aircraft with
under an enhanced equipment trust certificate ("EETC") financing arrangement.
The debt bears interest ranging from 4.75% to 6.25% and requires semi-annual
principal and interest payments. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$191.2 million outstanding under these notes.
? In fiscal year 2017, we financed eight E-175 aircraft with
debt. The senior notes payable of
three-month LIBOR plus a spread ranging from 2.20% to 2.32% (4.29% to 4.41%
at
The subordinated notes payable bear interest at 4.50% and require quarterly
principal and interest payments. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 , we had$152.9 million outstanding under these notes. ? InDecember 2017 , we refinanced$41.9 million of debt on nine CRJ-900
aircraft (due between 2019 and 2022) with
net cash proceeds to us of
senior notes payable of
3.5% (5.59% at
interest at three-month LIBOR plus 4.5% (6.59% at
refinanced debt requires quarterly payments of principal and interest. As of
? On
(due in 2019), with
us of
interest at LIBOR, plus 3.50% and require quarterly payments of principal and
interest. As of
these notes.
? On
leased under the GECAS Lease Facility, for
aircraft purchase with
2018 aircraft refinancing. The notes payable of
at LIBOR plus a spread ranging from 3.50% for the senior promissory notes to
7.50% for the subordinated promissory notes and require quarterly payments of
principal and interest. We recorded non-cash lease termination expense of
part of the transaction, we (i) received
services credits and
maturity date in 2027 from the aircraft manufacturer, and (ii) mutually
agreed with
of
? On
leased under GECAS Lease Facility, for
aircraft purchase with
the monthly LIBOR plus 5.25% (7.27% at
monthly principal and interest payments. As of
The Aircraft Notes are secured by the respective aircraft, which had a net book value of$894.3 million as ofSeptember 30, 2019 . The weighted-average effective interest rate of the fixed and floating rate aircraft and equipment notes, as ofSeptember 30, 2019 andSeptember 30, 2018 , was 5.25% and 5.66%, respectively.
Maintenance Commitments
InAugust 2005 , we entered into a ten-year agreement with AAR, for the maintenance and repair of certain of our CRJ-200, CRJ-700 and CRJ-900 aircraft. The agreement has since been amended to include a term extending through 2021, and to provide certain E-175 aircraft rotable spare parts with a term throughDecember 2027 . Under the agreements, we pay AAR a monthly access fee per aircraft for certain consigned inventory as well as a fixed "cost per flight hour" fee on a monthly basis for repairs on certain repairable parts during the term of the agreement, which fees are subject to annual adjustment based on increases in the cost of labor and component parts. InJuly 2013 , we entered into an engine maintenance contract withGE to perform heavy maintenance on certain CRJ-700, CRJ-900 and E-175 engines based on a fixed pricing schedule. The pricing may escalate annually in accordance withGE's spare parts catalog for engines. The engine maintenance contract extends through 2024. In 2014, we entered into a ten-year contract withAviall to provide maintenance and repair services on the wheels, brakes and tires of our CRJ-700 and CRJ-900 aircraft. Under the agreement, we payAviall a fixed "cost per landing" fee for all landings of our aircraft during the term of the agreement, which fee is subject to annual adjustment based on increases in the cost of labor and component parts. 57 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- We entered into an engine maintenance contract with StandardAero, which became effective onJune 1, 2015 , to perform heavy maintenance on certain CRJ-700 and CRJ-900 engines based on a fixed pricing schedule. The pricing may escalate annually in accordance with theGE's spare parts catalog for engines. The engine maintenance contract extends through 2020. Our employees perform routine airframe and engine maintenance along with periodic inspections of equipment at their respective maintenance facilities. We also use third-party vendors, such as AAR,Aviall andGE , for certain heavy airframe and engine maintenance work, along with parts procurement and component overhaul services for our aircraft fleet. As ofSeptember 30, 2019 ,$59.9 million of parts inventory was consigned to us by AAR andAviall under long-term contracts that is not reflected on our balance sheet. We use the direct expense method of accounting for our maintenance of regional jet engine overhauls, airframe, landing gear, and normal recurring maintenance wherein we recognize the expense when the maintenance work is completed, or over the repair period, if materially different. Our maintenance policy is determined by fleet when major maintenance is incurred. While we keep a record of expected maintenance events, the actual timing and costs of major engine maintenance expense are subject to variables such as estimated usage, government regulations and the level of unscheduled maintenance events and their actual costs. Accordingly, we cannot reliably quantify the costs or timing of future maintenance-related expenses for any significant period of time.
Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements
An off-balance sheet arrangement is any transaction, agreement or other contractual arrangement involving an unconsolidated entity under which a company has (i) made guarantees, (ii) a retained or a contingent interest in transferred assets, (iii) an obligation under derivative instruments classified as equity or (iv) any obligation arising out of a material variable interest in an unconsolidated entity that provides financing, liquidity, market risk or credit risk support to the company, or that engages in leasing, hedging or research and development arrangements with the company. We have no off-balance sheet arrangements of the types described in the four categories above that we believe may have material current or future effect on financial condition, liquidity or results of operations. A majority of our leased aircraft are leased through trusts formed for the sole purpose of purchasing, financing and leasing aircraft to us. Because these are single-owner trusts in which we do not participate, we are not at risk for losses and we are not considered the primary beneficiary. We believe that our maximum exposure under the leases are the remaining lease payments and any return condition obligations.
Critical Accounting Policies
We prepare our consolidated financial statements in accordance with GAAP. In doing so, we must make estimates and assumptions that affect our reported amounts of assets, liabilities, revenue and expenses, as well as related disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities. To the extent that there are material differences between these estimates and actual results, our financial condition or results of operations would be affected. We base our estimates on past experience and other assumptions that we believe are reasonable under the circumstances, and we evaluate these estimates on an ongoing basis. We refer to accounting estimates of this type as critical accounting estimates, which we discuss below.
We have identified the accounting policies discussed below as critical to us. The discussion below is not intended to be a comprehensive list of our accounting policies. Our significant accounting policies are more fully described in Note 2: "Summary of Significant Accounting Policies" to the consolidated financial statements.
Adoption of New Revenue Standard
OnOctober 1, 2018 , the Company adopted ASU No. 2014-09, Revenue from Contracts with Customers (Topic 606) ("ASU 2014-09" or "ASC 606") using the modified retrospective method. See Note 3: "Recent Accounting Pronouncements" in the notes to our consolidated financial statements for more information. To conform to ASC 606, the Company modified its revenue recognition policy as described below. 58
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Revenue Recognition
The Company recognizes revenue when the service is provided under its capacity purchase agreements. Under these agreements, the major airline partners generally pay a fixed monthly minimum amount per aircraft, plus certain additional amounts based upon the number of flights and block hours flown. The contracts also include reimbursement of certain costs incurred by the Company in performing flight services. These costs, known as "pass-through costs," may include passenger and hull insurance as well as aircraft property taxes. Additionally, for the E-175 aircraft owned by United, the capacity purchase agreement provides that United will reimburse the Company for heavy airframe and engine maintenance, landing gear, APUs and component maintenance. The Company also receives compensation under its capacity purchase agreements for heavy maintenance expenses at a fixed hourly rate or per aircraft rate for all aircraft in scheduled service other than the E-175 aircraft owned by United. The contracts also include a profit margin on certain reimbursable costs, as well as a profit margin, incentives and penalties based on certain operational benchmarks. The Company is eligible to receive incentive compensation upon the achievement of certain performance criteria defined in the capacity purchase agreements. At the end of each period during the term of an agreement, the Company calculates the incentives achieved during that period and recognizes revenue attributable to the agreement during the period accordingly, subject to the variable constraint guidance under ASC 606. All revenue recognized under these contracts is presented as the gross amount billed to the major airline partners. Under the capacity purchase agreements, the Company has committed to perform various activities that can be generally classified into in-flight services and maintenance services. When evaluating these services, the Company determined that the nature of its promise is to provide a single integrated service, flight services, because its contracts require integration and assumption of risk associated with both services to effectively deliver and provide the flights as scheduled over the contract term. Therefore, the in-flight services and maintenance services are inputs to that combined integrated flight service. Both the services occur over the term of the agreement and the performance of maintenance services significantly effects the utility of the in-flight services. The Company's individual flights flown under the capacity purchase agreements are deemed to be distinct and the flight service promised in the capacity purchase agreements represents a series of services that should be accounted for as a single performance obligation. This single performance obligation is satisfied over time as the flights are completed. Therefore, revenue is recognized when each flight is completed. In allocating the transaction price, variable payments (i.e. billings based on flights and block hours flown, pass-through costs, etc.) that relate specifically to the Company's efforts in performing flight services are recognized in the period in which the individual flight is completed. The Company has concluded that allocating the variability directly to the individual flights results in an overall allocation meeting the objectives in ASC 606. This results in a pattern of revenue recognition that follows the variable amounts billed from the Company to their customers. A portion of the Company's compensation under its capacity purchase agreements with American and United is designed to reimburse the Company for certain aircraft ownership costs. The Company has concluded that a component of its revenue under these agreements is deemed to be lease revenue, as such agreements identify the "right of use" of a specific type and number of aircraft over a stated period-of-time. The lease revenue associated with the Company's capacity purchase agreements is accounted for as an operating lease and is reflected as contract revenue on the Company's condensed consolidated statements of operations. The Company recognized$219.0 million ,$217.0 million and 217.6 million of lease revenue for the twelve months endedSeptember 30, 2019 , 2018 and 2017, respectively. The Company has not separately stated aircraft rental income and aircraft rental expense in the condensed consolidated statements of operations because the use of the aircraft is not a separate activity of the total service provided. The Company's capacity purchase agreements are renewable periodically and contain provisions pursuant to which the parties could terminate their respective agreements, subject to certain conditions as described in Note 1. The capacity purchase agreements also contain terms with respect to covered aircraft, services provided and compensation as described in Note 1. The capacity purchase agreements are amended from time to time to change, add or delete terms of the agreements. The Company's revenues could be impacted by a number of factors, including amendment or termination of its capacity purchase agreements, contract modifications resulting from contract renegotiations, its ability to earn incentive payments contemplated under applicable agreements, and settlement of reimbursement disputes with the Company's major airline partners. In the event contracted rates are not finalized at a quarterly or annual financial statement date, the Company evaluates the enforceability of its contractual terms and when it has an enforceable right, it estimates the amount the Company expects to be entitled to that is subject to the ASC 606 constraint. 59 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Company's capacity purchase agreements contain an option that allows its major airline partners to assume the contractual responsibility for procuring and providing the fuel necessary to operate the flights that it operates for them. Both of the Company's major airline partners have exercised this option. Accordingly, the Company does not record an expense or revenue for fuel and related fueling costs for flying under its capacity purchase agreements. In addition, the Company's major airline partners also provide, at no cost to the Company, certain ground handling and customer service functions, as well as airport-related facilities and gates at their hubs and other cities. Services and facilities provided by the Company's major airline partners at no cost are presented net in its condensed consolidated financial statements; hence, no amounts are recorded for revenue or expense for these items.
Maintenance Expense
We operate under anFAA -approved continuous inspection and maintenance program. We use the direct expense method of accounting for our maintenance of regional jet engine overhauls, airframe, landing gear, and normal recurring maintenance wherein we recognize the expense when the maintenance work is completed, or over the repair period, if materially different. Our maintenance policy is determined by fleet when major maintenance is incurred. For leased aircraft, we are subject to lease return provisions that require a minimum portion of the "life" of an overhaul be remaining on the engine at the lease return date. We estimate the cost of maintenance lease return obligations and accrue such costs over the remaining lease term when the expense is probable and can be reasonably estimated. Under our aircraft operating lease agreements andFAA operating regulations, we are obligated to perform all required maintenance activities on our fleet, including component repairs, scheduled air frame checks and major engine restoration events. We estimate the timing of the next major maintenance event based on assumptions including estimated usage,FAA -mandated maintenance intervals and average removal times as recommended by the manufacturer. The timing and the cost of maintenance are based on estimates, which can be impacted by changes in utilization of our aircraft, changes in government regulations and suggested manufacturer maintenance intervals. Major maintenance events consist of overhauls to major components. Engine overhaul expense totaled$30.0 million ,$51.2 million and$64.0 million for our fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2019 , 2018 and 2017, respectively, of which$6.0 million ,$12.3 million and$0.3 , respectively, was pass-through expense. Airframe C-check expense totaled$17.2 million ,$21.5 million and$22.6 million for our fiscal years endedSeptember 30, 2019 , 2018, and 2017, respectively, of which$0.4 million ,$7.5 million and$4.9 , respectively, was pass-through expense. Aircraft Leases In addition to the aircraft we receive from United under our Capacity Purchase Agreement, approximately 19% of our aircraft are leased from third parties. In order to determine the proper classification of a lease as either an operating lease or a capital lease, we must make certain estimates at the inception of the lease relating to the economic useful life and the fair value of an asset as well as select an appropriate discount rate to be used in discounting future lease payments. These estimates are utilized by management in making computations as required by existing accounting standards that determine whether the lease is classified as an operating lease or a capital lease. All of our aircraft leases have been classified as operating leases, which results in rental payments being charged to expense over the term of the related leases. Additionally, operating leases are not reflected in our consolidated balance sheets and accordingly, neither a lease asset nor an obligation for future lease payments is reflected in our consolidated balance sheets. In the event that we or one of our major airline partners decide to exit an activity involving leased aircraft, losses may be incurred. In the event that we exit an activity that results in exit losses, these losses are accrued as each aircraft is removed from operations for early termination penalties, lease settle up and other charges. See Note 3: "Recent Accounting Pronouncements" in the notes to our consolidated financial statements below for a discussion of a new accounting standard that is likely to have an impact on our aircraft lease accounting beginning in 2020. Income Taxes Income taxes are accounted for using the asset and liability method. Under this method, deferred income tax assets and liabilities are recognized for the future tax consequences attributable to temporary differences between the financial statement carrying amounts of existing assets and liabilities and their respective tax bases. Deferred income tax assets and liabilities are measured using enacted tax rates expected to apply to taxable income in the years in which these temporary differences are expected to be recovered or settled. The effect on deferred tax assets and liabilities of a change in tax rates is recognized in income in the period that includes the enactment date. A valuation allowance is provided for those deferred tax assets for which we cannot conclude that it is more likely than not that such deferred tax assets will be realized. 60 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In determining the amount of the valuation allowance, estimated future taxable income, as well as feasible tax planning strategies for each taxing jurisdiction, are considered. If we determine it is more likely than not that all or a portion of the remaining deferred tax assets will not be realized, the valuation allowance will be increased with a charge to income tax expense. Conversely, if we determine we are more likely than not to be able to utilize all or a portion of the deferred tax assets for which a valuation allowance has been provided, the related portion of the valuation allowance will be recorded as a reduction to income tax expense. We recognize and measure benefits for uncertain tax positions using a two-step approach. The first step is to evaluate the tax position taken or expected to be taken in a tax return by determining if the weight of available evidence indicates that is it more likely than not that the tax positions will be sustained upon audit, including resolution of any related appeals or litigation processes. For tax positions that are more likely than not to be sustained upon audit, the second step is to measure the tax benefit as the largest amount that is more than 50% likely to be realized upon settlement. Our practice is to recognize interest and/or penalties related to income tax matters in income tax expense. Significant judgment is required to evaluate uncertain tax positions. Evaluations are based upon a number of factors, including changes in facts or circumstances, changes in tax law, correspondence with tax authorities during the course of tax audits and effective settlement of audit issues. Changes in the recognition or measurement of uncertain tax positions could result in material increases or decreases in income tax expense in the period in which the change is made, which could have a material impact to our effective tax rate. See Note 12: "Income Taxes" in the notes to our consolidated financial statements included elsewhere in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for additional information. See also "Management's Discussion and Analysis-Results of Operations-Income Taxes" for additional information. For a further listing and discussion of our accounting policies, see Note 2: "Summary of Significant Accounting Policies" in the notes to our audited consolidated financial statements included elsewhere in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
Accounting Methodology for Stock Appreciation Rights
Our SARs and the restricted stock units granted under our Restricted Phantom Stock Units Plan ("Phantom Stock") historically were accounted for as liability compensatory awards under Accounting Standards Codification ("ASC") 710, Compensation - General, valued using the intrinsic value method, as permitted by ASC 718, Compensation - Stock Compensation ("ASC 718"), for nonpublic entities. Upon becoming a public company, as defined in ASC 718, in the third quarter of our fiscal 2018, we were required to change our methodology for valuing our SARs and Phantom Stock. Accordingly, our SARs and Phantom Stock were re-measured at each quarterly reporting date and were accounted for prospectively at fair value using a Black-Scholes fair value pricing model, until they were converted to restricted stock awards in connection with our IPO. We recorded the impact of the change in valuation methods as a cumulative effect of a change in accounting principle, as permitted by ASC 250, Accounting Changes and Error Corrections. The effect of the change increased our SARs and Phantom Stock liability by$2.4 million , which was the difference in compensation cost measured using the intrinsic value method and the fair value method. An equal and offsetting change to retained earnings in the consolidated balance sheet was recorded with the revaluation. In connection with our IPO, our SARs and Phantom Stock were cancelled and exchanged for shares of restricted stock under our 2018 Equity Incentive Plan.
Emerging Growth Company Status
The JOBS Act permits an "emerging growth company" such as us to take advantage of an extended transition period to comply with new or revised accounting standards applicable to public companies until those standards would otherwise apply to private companies. We have irrevocably elected to "opt out" of this provision and, as a result, we will comply with new or revised accounting standards when they are required to be adopted by public companies that are not emerging growth companies.
Recent Accounting Pronouncements
For a discussion of recent accounting pronouncements, see Note 3: "Recent Accounting Pronouncements" in the notes to our consolidated financial statements included elsewhere in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
61
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Edgar Online, source