Log in
Show password
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 
News: Latest News
Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesInterest RatesBusiness LeadersFinance Pro.CalendarSectors 

Carnegie Mellon University : Researchers Study Whether Renewable Is Always Better

07/19/2016 | 12:43pm EST

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Making plastics from plants is a growing trend. It's renewable, but is it better?

A recent study by Carnegie Mellon University researchers examines the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of three plant-based plastics at each stage of production compared with that of their common fossil fuel-based counterparts.

The study by Daniel Posen, Paulina Jaramillo and Michael Griffin in the Department of Engineering and Public Policy (EPP), was published in the Journal of Environmental Science and Technology.

The study is novel in the way it treats uncertainty and looks at emissions over the life cycle of plastics. The researchers used a technique called life cycle assessment that analyzes emissions at each stage in the life of a product: resource extraction to manufacturing, to use of the product and end of life.

'At each stage, you look at what is going on, what the different inputs are, and what's likely to be coming out the other end,' said Posen, a Ph.D. student in EPP and Civil and Environmental Engineering. 'Adding all of these scenarios together can get quite complicated because you have to decide how far you want to go back.'

While other research has been done on this topic, this study incorporates uncertainty and analyzes multiple scenarios that affect the overall carbon footprint.

For example, nitrous oxide (N2O) is emitted into the air from the fertilizer used to grow corn. And, if the crop of one cornfield is used as a feedstock to produce plastics, then a cornfield may need to be grown somewhere else for food. The consequences extend all the way to deforestation in Brazil, where forests are cut down to grow corn or other crops on the land.

'We've created a more complete model,' explained Posen, 'creating different scenarios, looking at uncertainty and any kind of parameter that goes into the analysis of emissions. We've built a big model to try and understand, 'Do bio-based plastics make sense?''

The study stresses the importance of considering uncertainty.

Instead of working under assumptions for the amount of fertilizer that becomes N2O emissions, Posen used a Monte Carlo method, or an approach that runs an experiment many times to generate many samples, to treat that uncertainty. Posen created a more accurate picture of the real percentage of emissions by generating a range of percentages instead of one assumption. Using materials with lower uncertainty could give companies confidence in their ability to reduce emissions.

The researchers also looked at the plastics in terms of their 'feedstocks,' or the material from which the plastics are derived. Most bio-based plastics are made from corn, but switchgrass is a lower-emission material that may emit fewer pollutants than fossil fuel-based plastics.

Posen and Jaramillo, an associate professor of EPP, will use the results of the study to continue looking into how best to reduce emissions from plastics. In the future, they will continue to ask if there is a better way to reduce emissions through renewable energy in the production process.

'What we've published here is the key model and a big picture look at emissions,' Posen said. 'We will use it to look at more specific questions about reducing emissions through energy.'


Carnegie Mellon University published this content on 19 July 2016 and is solely responsible for the information contained herein.
Distributed by Public, unedited and unaltered, on 19 July 2016 16:43:01 UTC.

© Publicnow 2016
Latest news "Commodities"
05:54pRio Tinto Says Pandemic Remains Threat to Mongolia Copper Exports -- Commodity Comment
05:01pRio Tinto Full-Year Australian Iron-Ore Shipments Fall; Sees 2022 Exports Likely Higher
04:52pRio Tinto sees soft 2022 iron ore shipments on labour issues, project delays
04:25pRio Tinto quarterly iron ore shipments fall 5%
03:47pUkraine says EU allows resumption of imports of Ukrainian poultry
03:46pUAE's ADNOC activates business continuity plans after refinery incident
03:45pVista Oil pays German firm $140 million for half its stake in Argentina concessions
03:08pFront Month ICE Brent Crude Rose 0.49% to Settle at $86.48 -- Data Talk
02:02pEU advisers concerned about plan for green labels on gas, nuclear investments
01:16pFrench power policy shift has left EDF in shock, CEO says
Latest news "Commodities"