Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  News  >  Economy & Forex

News : Latest News
Latest NewsCompaniesMarketsEconomy & ForexCommoditiesInterest RatesBusiness LeadersFinance Pro.CalendarSectors 
All NewsEconomyCurrencies & ForexEconomic EventsCryptocurrenciesCybersecurityPress Releases

Supreme Court Justices Question IRS Shield in Tax-Shelter Case

12/01/2020 | 05:00pm EST

By Richard Rubin and Brent Kendall

WASHINGTON -- Supreme Court justices sharply questioned arguments by the federal government that certain tax regulations can't be challenged in court before they are enforced.

Justices across the ideological spectrum, including Samuel Alito, Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan and Neil Gorsuch, expressed skepticism about the government's position during an hour-long oral argument Tuesday. A ruling against the government would make it harder for the Internal Revenue Service to demand and collect information that it uses to police tax shelters and could invite more-frequent legal challenges.

The case involves a requirement that taxpayers and their advisers disclose certain questionable transactions when they file their returns. They face tax penalties if they don't comply. That disclosure effectively attaches a red flag to those tax returns, letting the IRS more easily identify which ones to audit.

The taxpayer in question, CIC Services LLC, helps companies create what are known as captive insurers, subsidiaries that can get favorable tax treatment. For several years, the IRS has been questioning many captive-insurance arrangements, warning that they can be abusive tax shelters if they move money to a tax-favored entity without insuring genuine risks. In 2016, the agency issued a notice requiring disclosure of certain captive-insurance transactions.

The court isn't considering the merits of captive insurance but instead is examining the ways taxpayers can fight the IRS in court.

Generally, taxpayers trying to challenge the IRS have two paths. They can wait for an IRS assessment, refuse to pay and then go to the U.S. Tax Court. Or they can pay taxes and then sue in federal district court for a refund.

But they have less leeway to challenge regulations before the IRS enforces them because of the Anti-Injunction Act, a longstanding statute that bars lawsuits that attempt to prevent the assessment or collection of taxes. The idea is that taxpayers shouldn't be able to frustrate the important work of tax collection by filing lawsuits.

The act and Supreme Court precedent "make clear that a suit cannot proceed if the relief it seeks would legally bar the IRS from collecting a tax," Justice Department lawyer Jonathan Bond said.

CIC argued that the Anti-Injunction Act shouldn't apply in this regard because there is no assessment or collection that is part of the disclosure requirement.

Justice Kagan suggested that she agreed with CIC's position, saying the point of the company's lawsuit wasn't to avoid the tax penalty that stems from noncompliance but to challenge the requirement itself.

"They're trying to invalidate a demand that they disclose information," she said.

The company's lawyer, Cameron Norris, argued that the government's stance would require CIC to willfully violate the law in order to challenge it, subjecting itself to penalties or even prosecution.

Write to Richard Rubin at richard.rubin@wsj.com and Brent Kendall at brent.kendall@wsj.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

12-01-20 1659ET

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
LONDON BRENT OIL -0.18% 55.94 Delayed Quote.7.08%
WTI -0.12% 52.668 Delayed Quote.8.49%
Latest news "Economy & Forex"
05:54pTwitter permanently suspends My Pillow CEO for election misinformation
05:54pHHS names Susan Orsega as acting surgeon general
05:45pAlan Mnuchin-backed SPAC in talks to take Sharecare public -sources
05:44pTwitter permanently suspends My Pillow CEO for election misinformation
05:44pUtilities Down As Investors Hedge Bets Ahead Of Earnings -- Utilities Roundup
05:43pCommunications Services Up On Growth Bias -- Communications Services Roundup
05:37pOil Search sees 'another challenging year', lower output in 2021
05:36pTech Up Ahead Of Earnings, Microsoft Adds To Gains After Bell -- Tech Roundup
05:32pU.S. says $35 billion more in pandemic loans approved, trying to fix program snags
05:29pFinancials Down As Treasury-Yield Rally Stalls, UBS Rises -- Financials Roundup
Latest news "Economy & Forex"