Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Indexes  >  USA  >  S&P 500    SP500

S&P 500

SummaryMost relevantAll NewsNews of the index componentsMarketScreener Strategies

'Long-Short' Funds Missed Their Moment -- Journal Report

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
08/09/2020 | 04:14pm EDT

By Simon Constable

The stock-market volatility in the first half of 2020 should have been a near-perfect period for "long-short" mutual funds and exchange-traded funds to make a killing.

Unfortunately, less than one in three such funds made money for investors during this tumultuous period.

Long-short funds are those that allow portfolio managers to bet on securities they expect to rise in price, as well as those they expect to fall in price. They accomplish the latter through short selling, or selling borrowed stock in the hopes of repurchasing it at lower prices for a profit. Most traditional funds allow managers only to go long, or benefit from increasing prices.

"This seemed like it was a great environment for long-short strategies as we saw U.S. equities fall into a bear market and subsequently recover much of the losses," says Todd Rosenbluth, head of ETF and mutual-fund research at CFRA.

SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY), an exchange-traded fund that tracks the S&P 500 stock index, fell more than 30% from Feb. 19 through March 20, according to Yahoo. By the end of June, it was down only 8.4% as the market rebounded. (Neither figure includes dividends.)

Theoretically, long-short funds should have been able to profit from the initial drop in the market in late February and much of March by selling borrowed stock. The funds then had an opportunity to add to those gains by buying stocks ahead of the subsequent rally that started on March 23.

Yet, as Mr. Rosenbluth points out, the majority of funds in the category lost money, some substantially.

Only 30 of the 99 funds that fit into this so-called long-short category reported gains in the first half of the year, according to data from Morningstar.

ProShares Long Online/Short Stores ETF (CLIX) performed best over the 26 weeks, with total a return of 48%. The worst performer was Pzena Long/Short Value Fund (PZILX), which lost 28%.

Part of the problem for long-short fund managers was that the selloff and rebound occurred so rapidly. "Investors had to be great at timing the market to capture both sides of the trade," Mr. Rosenbluth says.

In addition, there typically are few restrictions on how the managers of long-short funds are allowed to invest money. "They are like a blank canvas," Mr. Rosenbluth says, which explains the wide dispersion of returns from the 99 funds in the group.

Making things more challenging for fund managers was a divergence in the performance of individual stocks that before the crisis were viewed as direct competitors, says Jack Ablin, chief investment officer and founding partner at the wealth management company Cresset Capital.

Netflix and Walt Disney, for example, "went into 2020 as head-to-head rivals in the entertainment business, and coronavirus drove a wedge between the two as the latter had to close its theme parks," Mr. Ablin says. Meanwhile, Netflix got a boost from streaming video from people stuck at home.

Put another way, Covid-19 in some ways changed the nature of the economy and hence the nature of stock picking. In turn that made it more challenging for fund managers to sort the winners from the losers

Overall, money flew out of the long-short sector, but one fund stood out, Neuberger Berman Long Short Fund (NLSIX), which attracted $824 million in new assets over the period.

Mr. Constable is a writer in Edinburgh, Scotland. He can be reached at reports@wsj.com.


Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
DJ INDUSTRIAL -0.11% 28170.04 Delayed Quote.-1.15%
MORNINGSTAR, INC. -0.08% 184.125 Delayed Quote.21.79%
NASDAQ 100 -0.60% 11567.643563 Delayed Quote.33.72%
NASDAQ COMP. -0.59% 11410.045346 Delayed Quote.28.00%
NETFLIX, INC. -1.26% 482.4 Delayed Quote.51.14%
S&P 500 -0.13% 3429.49 Delayed Quote.6.57%
THE WALT DISNEY COMPANY 0.19% 126.69 Delayed Quote.-12.45%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
All news about S&P 500
11:21aWall Street drops in choppy trade as investors look for stimulus
11:01aWALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : U.S. Stocks Edge Lower as Investors Eye Stimulus Ta..
10:45aStimulus hopes alive but sentiment sapped by COVID surge
10:09aWALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : U.S. Stocks Edge Higher as Investors Eye Stimulus T..
09:49aWALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : U.S. Stocks Edge Higher as Investors Eye Stimulus T..
08:45aWALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : Wall Street Profits Soar During First Half of 2020
07:12aWALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : Dow quarterly profit beats on demand recovery, cost..
06:58aU.S. Stock Futures Point Lower as Investors Eye Stimulus Talks
06:24aU.S. Stock Futures Point Lower as Investors Eye Stimulus Talks
05:36aU.S. Stock Futures Point Lower as Investors Eye Stimulus Talks
More news
Chart S&P 500
Duration : Period :
S&P 500 Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends S&P 500
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Top / Flop S&P 500
ALIGN TECHNOLOGY, INC. 438.64 Real-time Estimate Quote.30.62%
SNAP-ON 167.25 Real-time Estimate Quote.7.72%
LAS VEGAS SANDS CORP. 49.465 Real-time Estimate Quote.7.67%
EXPEDIA GROUP, INC. 98.37 Real-time Estimate Quote.6.12%
DISCOVER FINANCIAL SERVICES 64.215 Real-time Estimate Quote.5.97%
EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORPORATION 79.305 Real-time Estimate Quote.-5.15%
UNION PACIFIC 187.975 Real-time Estimate Quote.-5.77%
TRACTOR SUPPLY COMPANY 140.31 Real-time Estimate Quote.-5.91%
CITRIX SYSTEMS, INC. 127.195 Real-time Estimate Quote.-6.72%
CINCINNATI FINANCIAL CORPORATION 77.975 Real-time Estimate Quote.-7.49%
Heatmap :