Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

S&P 500

SummaryMost relevantAll NewsOther languagesNews of the index componentsMarketScreener Strategies

Reopening economy too early could backfire for humans and markets, investors say

03/24/2020 | 05:11am EDT
FILE PHOTO: Traders work on the floor of the NYSE in New York

U.S. President Donald Trump's desire to rapidly reopen the economy despite signs the coronavirus is still spreading may backfire, with higher deaths and citizens remaining fearful of going out, some investors said.

U.S. markets have been roiled by the spread of the virus in the country and as states have shut parts of their economies.

Trump said on Monday that at the end of a 15-day shutdown period, which would run to the end of the month, "we will make a decision as to which way we want to go."

Last week, Trump urged Americans to halt most social activities for 15 days. It is unclear what power Trump actually has to simply turn the economy back on by executive order.

News of Trump reopening the U.S. economy anytime soon would not be taken well by investors, who remain anxious about the coronavirus? uncertain trajectory and its economic toll, said Axel Merk, chief investment officer of Merk Investments.

"Markets will react badly because they have learned that this approach doesn't work," Merk said. "From a medical point of view, you have to break the exponential growth and you do that with shelter in place policies."

The S&P 500 sank 3% on Monday. It is down more than 30% from its Feb. 19 peak and is at levels not seen since the end of 2016, giving up nearly all of its gains from before Trump was elected.


Initial estimates of the pandemic?s economic fallout have grown bleaker in recent days.

U.S. unemployment could hit 30% and second-quarter economic output could be half the norm, St. Louis Federal Reserve President James Bullard said.

Jennifer Pline, head of wealth management for Cambridge Trust in Boston, said it is too soon to judge whether to reopen the economy just yet.

"As we?re just starting to close things down fairly tightly, we need to wait a while until we get more traction and less contagion with the virus."

The cost of a mistake could be deadly. A March 16 study by Imperial College in London predicts 2.2 million deaths in the United States in an unmitigated epidemic, with critical care bed capacity exceeded as early as the second week in April.

Economists at Northwestern University and Berlin?s Freie University estimated an ?optimal containment policy? in the United States would deepen the subsequent recession but save 600,000 lives.

    Ellis Phifer, market strategist for Raymond James in Memphis, Tenn. said he has struggled with the question of whether it would be best to reopen parts of the economy.

?It?s really hard to determine which costs more,? Phifer said of the dueling approaches of lifting restrictions sooner or later. On balance, he would be inclined to follow the advice of public health experts like Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, who have largely advocated for more restrictions.


    In an interview last week, Richmond Federal Reserve president Thomas Barkin said any call to try to resume normal economic activity will depend on widespread testing quick enough that businesses can establish protocols to ensure worker and customer safety.

David Kotok, chairman & chief investment officer of Cumberland Advisors, said what is imperative is to get accurate antibody tests, and to read the recovery rate as well as confirmed cases and deaths.

"I don't think the market will get the economic growth if people are dying all over the place," said Kotok.

Others thought that the more important thing would be to get the economy back open.

"You leave this USA shut for another 60 days and you may have no economy or healthcare left," said John Lekas at Leader Capital.

Rob Arnott, founder of asset manager Research Affiliates said the toll of job losses and other economic hardship that may stem from shutdowns and other measures could potentially be more harmful than the virus itself.

?Our way of handling this will kill a lot more people than it saves,? said Arnott.

But now the measures are taken and the population is fearful, there may be no going back.

Gregory Daco, Chief U.S, Economist at Oxford Economics, said even if the lockdowns were lifted, "businesses and households would remain very cautious, and financial intermediation would remain under stress... And, with the rest of the world under lockdown, you would presumably further alienate yourself."

(Reporting by Ross Kerber, Megan Davies, Ira Iosebashvili, Noel Randewich, Howard Schneider; writing by Megan Davies; editing by Lincoln Feast.)

By Ross Kerber and Megan Davies

© Reuters 2020
Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
BEST INC. 0.00% 1.38 Delayed Quote.-32.35%
DEERE & COMPANY 0.24% 383.07 Delayed Quote.42.03%
DJ INDUSTRIAL 0.48% 34200.67 Delayed Quote.11.21%
FORBO HOLDING AG 0.11% 1816 Delayed Quote.19.63%
NASDAQ 100 0.11% 14041.908091 Delayed Quote.8.95%
NASDAQ COMP. 0.10% 14052.342146 Delayed Quote.9.03%
S&P 500 0.36% 4185.47 Delayed Quote.11.03%
All news about S&P 500
09:00aTech retakes market lead as investors eye yields, earnings
04/16WALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : Wall Street closes with weekly gains
04/16CLOSE UPDATE : US Stocks Clinch Fresh Highs Amid Upbeat Economic Data, Earnings
04/16World stocks at new peaks on strong China, U.S. data
04/16WALL STREET STOCK EXCHANGE : Wall Street ends week positively; S&P 500, Dow hit ..
04/16S&P 500 Posts 1.4% Weekly Gain, Hits More Fresh Highs, as Utilities, Health C..
04/16US Stocks Clinch Fresh Highs Amid Upbeat Economic Data, Earnings
04/16STREET COLOR : US Treasury and Equity Closing Levels for Friday
04/16S&p 500 and dow jones industrial average end at record high closes
04/16SECTOR UPDATE : Tech Stocks Lack Direction as Chipmakers Fall
More news
Chart S&P 500
Duration : Period :
S&P 500 Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends S&P 500
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Heatmap :