Aire Technology sued Apple for patent infringement in
Apple argued that the district court abused its discretion in ordering the parties to complete 30 more weeks of fact discovery and six weeks of rebriefing the issue to decide on Apple's transfer request. Apple noted that by the time the district court considered Apple's motion, a full year would have elapsed since Apple initially sought the transfer, fact discovery would be completed, the parties' infringement and invalidity contentions would be served, the asserted claims and prior art references would be narrowed, and the parties would have exchanged preliminary trial exhibits and witness lists.
The Federal Circuit agreed with Apple that the district court's scheduling order went too far. The Court stated that "it is a clear abuse of discretion to require the parties to expend additional party and court resources litigating the substantive matters of the case while Apple's motion to transfer unnecessarily lingers on the docket." The Court noted that Aire consented to resolving Apple's transfer motion at any time, provided that no stay interfered with discovery, claim construction proceedings or preparation of the case for trial.
The Federal Circuit disagreed with the district court's view that delaying the decision until after full fact discovery and rebriefing could reduce "speculation" and "allow the parties to provide the court with the best evidence for ruling on a motion to transfer." The Court stated that discovery on the transfer motion itself was sufficient to allow a decision of that motion, especially because the parties agreed that further venue discovery was unnecessary. The Federal Circuit ordered the district court to "proceed expeditiously [on the transfer motion] as the first order of business."
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Ms
600 13th Street N.W.
20005-3096
Tel: 2075776900
Fax: 2075776950
E-mail: sliston@europe.mwe.com
URL: www.mwe.com
© Mondaq Ltd, 2022 - Tel. +44 (0)20 8544 8300 - http://www.mondaq.com, source