Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener Strategies

Investment Giants Lobby to Avoid Antitrust Scrutiny

04/08/2021 | 08:15am EDT

By Dawn Lim

Asset managers are fighting a proposal from U.S. antitrust authorities to tighten scrutiny over how these firms influence the way businesses operate and, in turn, the prices of everything from airline tickets to food.

In March, the asset-management industry pushed back on the proposed rule on a videocall with congressional staffers. Executives of Capital Group Cos., Fidelity Investments, Nuveen LLC and Wellington Management Co. joined alongside others, people familiar with the matter said. Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, a lobbying group, organized the call.

The industry's pitch was that filing burdens from the rules would cost investors. Some of those on the call said it would also create unnecessary delays that would make it harder for index funds to track benchmarks or for stock pickers to take opportunistic bets.

The proposed rule is coming from the Federal Trade Commission. It would require investment firms to file for antitrust review any time a manager's collective funds go above certain thresholds, in some cases this means holdings of more than 10% of a company. Right now, investment firms generally only have to alert regulators when a single fund takes a large-enough position in a company.

Government officials want to remove blind spots in how they monitor influential investors' impact on everyday consumers as asset managers, hedge funds and private-equity firms become ever-bigger forces in markets. Among regulators' concerns--and why it falls under antitrust rules--is the potential for these firms to exert anticompetitive pressure.

The proposed rule would affect one of the most powerful forces on Wall Street today: index managers. At least one of the biggest three-- BlackRock Inc., Vanguard Group and State Street Global Advisors--held 10% or more of roughly 200 companies in the S&P 500 through funds as of 2020, according to FactSet data. They collectively manage some $19 trillion for millions of investors.

Their growth has been a boon for the average investor, lowering investing costs and improving access to markets. But the concentration of power in these firms potentially affects the wider economy. An unsettled regulatory debate involves the anticompetitive effects of investment firms that own stakes in many companies in one industry. Some regulators are concerned such firms could unintentionally distort market forces by failing to push companies to compete.

In its draft proposal, the FTC exempted some firms from filing for antitrust review as long they had no more than 10% in a company and didn't hold stakes of more than 1% in a competitor to that company. But many index funds and others with sprawling stakes across the market wouldn't be able to use this exemption.

Managers both big and small have been lobbying to fend off the Trump-era proposed change to the Hart-Scott-Rodino rules, which require buyers to alert the government of certain transactions so regulators can get ahead of any antitrust violations.

"Sifma is concerned the proposed HSR aggregation rule will significantly burden Main Street investors, retirees and asset managers with no basis in antitrust experience or even in theory," Andrew Ruggiero, Sifma assistant general counsel, said in a statement.

The regulatory threat to the growth of index funds has been brewing for years. BlackRock's willingness to press companies for disclosures on everything from how they manage greenhouse-gas emissions to whether they are installing enough women on boards has come to reflect the rise of big investors. Chief Executive Larry Fink uses his yearly letter to CEOs to amplify the firm's voice as a corporate watchdog for investors.

In letters to the FTC, BlackRock has said it isn't dictating the daily management of companies. BlackRock and other managers have also spent years pushing back against academic research on the potential anticompetitive effects of managers with stakes across a sector.

The regulatory consequences of that debate weighed on index-fund pioneer and Vanguard founder Jack Bogle. In the months before his 2019 death, Mr. Bogle gathered close associates, including investing author Burton Malkiel and AQR Capital Management co-founder Cliff Asness, at Princeton University to discuss research on fund managers' effect on competition. Mr. Bogle recognized that index funds faced the threat of new regulation and expressed concerns to those there that the government would impose limits on index funds' holdings in companies.

"The way Jack Bogle, who always had a very colorful way of saying things, put it was, 'That would kill my baby,'" said Mr. Malkiel.

Since that Princeton gathering, large fund managers have faced even more dilemmas due to their size.

Many are pressured by activists to make companies do more on everything from climate risk to diversity. But if they are too prescriptive, they could be seen as regulators as too effective and too powerful.

In the lead-up to releasing the proposed rule, FTC officials debated how antitrust law should account for shareholder outreach, according to people familiar with the matter. Some officials pushed to provide guidance that would reassure firms that interactions with companies on governance and social matters wouldn't lead to heightened threat of antitrust review.

When the FTC released the draft rules in late 2020, it asked firms to describe their typical shareholder conversations with companies to help it decide what interactions veered into dictating a company's business plans--and whether that should subject firms to further antitrust scrutiny.

"Shareholder engagement can have a pro-competitive effect," FTC Commissioner Noah Phillips said in an interview. "We need to keep that in mind when structuring antitrust rules."

In letters to the agency this year, asset managers played down their influence as shareholders. They argued that they weren't activist investors, but simply making businesses attentive to shareholder risks. Vanguard said its shareholder interactions "do not seek to set or alter company strategy."

BlackRock said it and its peers "do not use stewardship engagements to dictate the day-to-day management activities" of companies. The world's biggest asset manager urged the FTC to soften the impact of the proposed rule on index funds and mutual funds.

It is unclear how the rule could morph with the FTC's leadership in flux. During a March hearing on monopoly issues, a lawmaker asked Mr. Phillips when the rule would be completed. The FTC official declined to give specifics on the timeline while the rule was still under review.

Write to Dawn Lim at dawn.lim@wsj.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

04-08-21 0814ET

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
BLACKROCK, INC. -0.78% 811.45 Delayed Quote.13.35%
DJ INDUSTRIAL 0.48% 34200.67 Delayed Quote.11.21%
NASDAQ 100 0.11% 14041.908091 Delayed Quote.8.83%
NASDAQ COMP. 0.10% 14052.342146 Delayed Quote.8.93%
S&P 500 0.36% 4185.47 Delayed Quote.11.03%
All news about BLACKROCK, INC.
04/16INSIDER TRENDS : BlackRock Insider Extends 90-Day Selling Trend
04/16INSIDER TRENDS : Selling By Insiders Lingers at BlackRock
04/16BLACKROCK  : Argus Adjusts Price Target on BlackRock to $915 From $845, Maintain..
04/16NORDEA BANK ABP : Flagging notification in accordance with Chapter 9, Section 10..
04/16BLACKROCK  : Deutsche Bank Adjusts BlackRock's Price Target to $912 From $847, M..
04/16BLACKROCK  : Barclays Adjusts Price Target on BlackRock to $925 From $850, Maint..
04/16BLACKROCK  : Credit Suisse Raises BlackRock's PT to $984 from $949, Notes Strong..
04/16BLACKROCK  : Morgan Stanley Adjusts Price Target on BlackRock to $944 From $924,..
04/16BLACKROCK  : Citigroup Adjusts BlackRock's Price Target to $1,000 From $950, Mai..
04/16SAMPO OYJ SAMPO PLC  : Disclosure Under Chapter 9 Section 5 Of The Securities Ma..
More news
Financials (USD)
Sales 2021 18 711 M - -
Net income 2021 5 660 M - -
Net cash 2021 4 029 M - -
P/E ratio 2021 22,0x
Yield 2021 2,00%
Capitalization 124 B 124 B -
EV / Sales 2021 6,40x
EV / Sales 2022 5,81x
Nbr of Employees 16 500
Free-Float 87,5%
Duration : Period :
BlackRock, Inc. Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends BLACKROCK, INC.
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus BUY
Number of Analysts 17
Average target price 895,75 $
Last Close Price 811,45 $
Spread / Highest target 21,3%
Spread / Average Target 10,4%
Spread / Lowest Target -9,42%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Laurence Douglas Fink Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
Robert Steven Kapito President & Non-Independent Director
Gary S. Shedlin Chief Financial Officer & Senior Managing Director
Derek N. Stein Global Head-Business Operations & Technology
Robert L. Goldstein Chief Operating Officer & Senior Managing Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
BLACKROCK, INC.13.35%123 860
UBS GROUP AG16.56%55 977
T. ROWE PRICE GROUP, INC.17.15%40 339