Introduction
We are pleased to present the latest edition of
- The '
Focus Point ' explores the aspects of Equalization Levy and its impact on e-commerce transactions. - Under the 'From the Judiciary' section, we provide in brief, the key rulings on important cases, and our take on the same.
-
Our 'Tax Talk' provides key updates on the important tax-related news from
India and across the globe. - Under 'Compliance Calendar', we list down the important due dates with regard to direct tax, transfer pricing and indirect tax in the month.
We hope you find our newsletter useful and we look forward to your feedback. You can write to us at taxstreet@nexdigm.com. We would be happy to hear your thoughts on what more can we include in our newsletter and incorporate your feedback in our future editions.
Warm regards,
The Nexdigm (SKP) Team
Budget 2020 extended the scope of EL to cover digital transactions. EL was extended to include e-commerce supply or service, including the online sale of goods or online provision of services or both facilitated/owned by e-commerce operators. For this purpose, an e-commerce operator means a non-resident who owns, operates, or manages digital or e-facility or platform for the online sale of goods or online provision of services or both.
The EL on these services was applicable at 2% of the consideration received on e-commerce supply of goods or services or both by the e-commerce operator for the sale or facilities provided to a resident in
However, since the terms online sale of goods and online provision of services were not defined, there was ambiguity around the applicability of levy. Also, there was a fear of double taxation in cases where payments were covered both under EL as well as taxable under Royalty/Fees For Technical Services (FTS) provisions.
following clarifications/amendments:
- EL shall not be applicable for cases where consideration for e-commerce supply or services is taxable as royalty or FTS in
India . Thus, taxation as royalty/fee for technical services under the Income-tax law would have priority over EL. -
Scope of online sale of goods/ online provision of services has been defined to include cases where one or more of the following activities are carried out online:
- Acceptance of an offer for sale; or
- Placing or acceptance of purchase order; or
- Payment of consideration; or
- Supply of goods or provision of services, partly or wholly.
- Acceptance of an offer for sale; or - Placing or acceptance of purchase order; or - Payment of consideration; or - Supply of goods or provision of services, partly or wholly.
- Consideration for the purpose of levy of EL clarified to include the value of goods or services, regardless of ownership or facilitation by the e-commerce operator.
- Further, these amendments shall be applicable retrospectively from AY 2021-22.
Our Comments
The new EL provisions would have a huge impact on various companies doing business with
Also, the clarification provided in respect of the definition of online sale of goods/online provision of services results in expanding the scope of EL even to non-digital transactions. The term 'digital or electronic facility or platform' has not been defined. In normal parlance, it could cover any digital communication that would include emails or calls, which would cover all kinds of cross-border transactions, where goods are ordered over call/online but delivery and payment is made through regular mode. No clarification has been provided whether a digital or electronic facility or platform includes only the transactions, which are concluded through technology, without physical involvement of any person or it would also include the one-to-one communication between the parties through emails, video call, etc. In our view, the intention of the levy was not to cover the transactions, where the same are concluded or delivered over emails, video calls, etc., given the current global trade scenario, such would be similar to physical supply of goods or services. However, such anomaly continues, as the tax authorities have not defined the term 'Online', and this may result in prolonged litigations unless appropriate clarifications are issued. Also, since payment of consideration is covered, it creates an ambiguity whether payments made through normal banking channels or through online banking platforms would also get covered.
One of the clarifications states that an e-commerce operator would be liable to pay the EL on the entire value of the transaction and not on the convenience fee received by them. This will result in significant hardship for the e-commerce operators as this levy may eat up their margins if they are not able to pass this on to their vendors. On the contrary, this clarification is a welcome step for Indian e-commerce operators since it will create a level-playing field between foreign and domestic companies.
Tax on Royalty/FTS and EL are considered mutually exclusive effective from
In addition to the above, provisions of Significant Economic Presence (SEP) would also be applicable from Financial Year 2021-22. While these provisions would become applicable from
To read the full article click here
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Urmi Axis, 7th Floor
400 011
Tel: 226730 9000
Fax: 226730 9000
E-mail: pooja.tolani@nexdigm.com
URL: www.skpgroup.com
© Mondaq Ltd, 2021 - Tel. +44 (0)20 8544 8300 - http://www.mondaq.com, source