Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Xetra  >  Hannover Rück SE    HNR1   DE0008402215


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener StrategiesAnalyst Recommendations

UK firms hail victory in battle over COVID-19 insurance claims

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
09/15/2020 | 07:51pm EDT
FILE PHOTO: Man walks past a closed retail outlet on a commercial road, in London

London judges have ruled that some of the world's biggest insurers were wrong to reject tens of thousands of claims from small firms battered by the COVID-19 pandemic, Britain's Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said on Tuesday.

The FCA, which brought the test case against eight insurers, said the court had found in favour of policyholders' arguments on the majority of key issues in a complex, 162-page judgment.

However, some of the insurers said the ruling meant they wouldn't have to pay out, or would have to pay out much less than modelled in a worse-case scenario, and Britain's Federation of Small Businesses called the judgment a "partial" victory.

The lawsuit has been closely watched because it is estimated to affect 370,000 businesses and billions in insurance claims.

The FCA brought the case against the insurers, including Hiscox, RSA, QBE and Zurich, in June to clarify whether 21 types of business interruption (BI) policy wordings should pay out for closures and disruption caused by the pandemic.

    The regulator has estimated the case could affect more than 60 insurers and 700 different types of policies because many insurance policies have similar wording. It is also being watched overseas, the LIIBA insurance brokers' trade body said.

Small businesses - from cafes, wedding planners and beauty parlours to events businesses - have said they faced ruin after attempts to claim compensation for business losses during the pandemic, which has prompted the most stringent government restrictions in peacetime history, were rejected by insurers.

FCA interim chief executive Christopher Woolard said the judgment was a "significant step" in resolving the uncertainty faced by policyholders and called on insurers to "reflect on the clarity provided", irrespective of any possible appeal, and consider how to progress claims.


But the devil was in the detail.

The Association of British Insurers (ABI) said the judgment "divided evenly" between insurers and policyholders on the main issues.

Zurich Insurance and Ecclesiastical [ELL.UL], a smaller insurer, said the judgment confirmed their disputed policies did not need to pay out.

Hiscox said fewer than one third of its 34,000 UK BI policies would have to pay out and that the net cost would be less than 100 million pounds ($129 million) - compared with initial guidance of up to 250 million pounds.

Shares in Hiscox and RSA, which restored its cancelled 2019 dividend and pointed out that some of its policy interpretations had been upheld by the court, leapt by 15% and 6% respectively, as the market welcomed the removal of uncertainty and a fresh focus on growth.

Australian-based QBE said it was considering its options to appeal the ruling, saying the decision overall was still largely in its favour.

It estimated its UK business interruption claims exposure at around A$170 million ($124 million) before allowing for recoveries under the group's catastrophe reinsurance protections.

Lloyd's of London insurer MS Amlin [MITSID.UL] said it would communicate with affected clients "in the coming days", while fellow Lloyd's insurers Arch and Argenta did not respond.

The Lloyd's of London commercial insurance market said it had strong enough capital to cope with the financial implications of the judgment.


But some policyholders were jubilant.

Justin Stead, CEO of accessories firm Radley London, said the judgment was "an extremely important outcome to secure the future for Radley", adding insurers should pay out quickly "to save as many businesses as possible".

Sonia Campbell, partner at law firm Mishcon de Reya, which represented two business action groups in the case, said the outcome was a "resounding victory" for many firms.

The FCA lawsuit offered a new legal route by pooling together a group of company policies and taking insurers to court with minimal costs to businesses.

The case was designed to quickly clarify whether the pandemic and a government lockdown in March should trigger BI policies, which provide cover when insured premises cannot be used because of restrictions imposed by a public authority and in the event of a notifiable disease or infection.

Insurers have argued that most policies did not cover the pandemic, that they were paying out valid claims as quickly as possible and that being forced to stump up for all losses from the pandemic would be catastrophic for the insurance industry, and its backup, the reinsurance industry.

If the judgment is appealed it could leapfrog straight to the Supreme Court, the highest UK court, to reduce delay for buckling businesses, lawyers say.

(Reporting by Kirstin Ridley and Carolyn Cohn, additional reporting by Swati Pandey in Sydney; editing by Sinead Cruise, Mark Potter and Lincoln Feast.)

By Carolyn Cohn and Kirstin Ridley

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
ARCH CAPITAL GROUP LTD. 0.41% 31.81 Delayed Quote.-25.83%
HANNOVER RÜCK SE 0.47% 129.6 Delayed Quote.-24.78%
HISCOX LTD -0.16% 875.6 Delayed Quote.-38.51%
QBE INSURANCE GROUP LIMITED 0.68% 8.86 End-of-day quote.-31.21%
RSA INSURANCE GROUP PLC 1.28% 443.6 Delayed Quote.-21.57%
ZURICH INSURANCE GROUP LTD 1.38% 315.1 Delayed Quote.-20.65%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
All news about HANNOVER RÜCK SE
10/22HANNOVER RÜCK SE : Preliminary announcement of the publication of quarterly repo..
10/21HANNOVER RUECKVERSICHERUNG AG : RBC reaffirms its Neutral rating
10/21HANNOVER RUECKVERSICHERUNG AG : Gets a Buy rating from DZ Bank
10/21HANNOVER RUECKVERSICHERUNG AG : Berenberg gives a Neutral rating
10/21HANNOVER RUECKVERSICHERUNG AG : JP Morgan reaffirms its Buy rating
10/19HANNOVER RÜCK : E+S Rück expects rising prices and improved conditions in 2021 f..
10/16HANNOVER RUECKVERSICHERUNG AG : Barclays remains a Sell rating
10/05HANNOVER RUECKVERSICHERUNG AG : Berenberg sticks Neutral
10/02FCA insurance test case appeal heads to Supreme Court
More news
Sales 2020 24 298 M 28 673 M 28 673 M
Net income 2020 797 M 940 M 940 M
Net Debt 2020 3 200 M 3 776 M 3 776 M
P/E ratio 2020 19,5x
Yield 2020 4,05%
Capitalization 15 557 M 18 404 M 18 358 M
EV / Sales 2020 0,77x
EV / Sales 2021 0,66x
Nbr of Employees 3 144
Free-Float 49,8%
Duration : Period :
Hannover Rück SE Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends HANNOVER RÜCK SE
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 23
Average target price 151,32 €
Last Close Price 129,00 €
Spread / Highest target 55,0%
Spread / Average Target 17,3%
Spread / Lowest Target -23,3%
EPS Revisions
Jean-Jacques Henchoz Chief Executive Officer
Torsten Leue Chairman-Supervisory Board
Clemens Jungsthöfel Chief Financial Officer
Herbert K. Haas Member-Supervisory Board
Erhard Walter Schipporeit Member-Supervisory Board
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
HANNOVER RÜCK SE-25.13%18 404
SWISS RE LTD-37.92%20 755
EVEREST RE GROUP, LTD.-25.21%8 276