Log in
Show password
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector news

Helix Energy : Fifth Circuit Rules Day Rate Compensation Does Not Satisfy Requirement Of Payment On A Salaried Basis For Exempt Status

09/25/2021 | 08:09am EDT

The issue of the proper application of the highly compensated employee exemption under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), as it applies to employees paid on a "day-rate" basis in the oil and gas industry, has been a hotly debated issue in recent years, especially in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. In August 2019, a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit concluded in Faludi v. U.S. Shale Solutions, LLC, that an oil and gas consultant who was paid $1,000 for every day he worked, with annual compensation of approximately $260,000, was properly classified as exempt under the highly compensated employee exemption, rejecting the consultant's overtime claim. The court concluded that the consultant's day rate of $1,000 satisfied the requirement that the employee receive a guaranteed salary of at least $455 per week. Faludi, the consultant, petitioned for en banc review before the Fifth Circuit, and while that was pending, the original panel withdrew its opinion and ruled that it "need not reach" the question of the highly compensated employee exemption, as Faludi was an independent contractor and therefore not entitled to overtime compensation under the FLSA. Thus, the court sidestepped the issue. (Although the Fifth Circuit dodged the issue by ruling Faludi was an independent contractor, it reiterated its support for the legal basis of its original opinion.)

The issue emerged again in 2020, in Hewitt v. Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. (Hewitt I). There, a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit, addressing the exempt status of a "Tool Pusher" on an oil rig who supervised around 12 to 14 other employees, was paid a daily rate of $963, and earned more than $200,000 annually, concluded that payment on a day-rate basis was not payment on a salaried basis. Therefore, he was not properly classified as an exempt, highly compensated employee, and he was entitled to overtime compensation. Later in 2020, the panel withdrew its opinion and issued a substitute opinion (Hewitt II), still ruling that payment on a day-rate basis did not satisfy the regulatory requirement of payment on a salaried basis. Judge Wiener, who initially agreed with the decision in Hewitt I, authored a strong dissenting opinion in Hewitt II, foreshadowing further debate on the issue.

Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc., petitioned for rehearing en banc, and the decision of the Fifth Circuit was vacated pending en banc review. On September 9, 2021, the Fifth Circuit issued its divided opinion (12-6), holding that payment on a day-rate basis "'does not constitute payment on a salary basis'" for the purpose of the highly compensated employee exemption. In addition, the court concluded that, because the employee was paid on a day-rate basis, the employer could not take advantage of the salary-basis test under 29 C.F.R. § 541.604(b) because the guaranteed salary did not have "'a reasonable relationship'" to the total income earned by the employee. The court concluded that the $963 daily rate was not reasonably related to the $3,846 the employee earned on average each week. Thus, the employee did not qualify for the exemption.

This has been, and still is, an extremely important issue for the oil and gas industry because of the way it staffs offshore and remote oil and gas work sites. Having to pay employees making upwards of $200,000 per year additional compensation for overtime, when they clearly meet the duties test for exempt status, was heavily briefed by the five states that weighed in on the subject, as they have much to lose if the oil and gas industry is adversely impacted by this decision. Amicus briefs filed by the oil and gas industry pointed out that cases in two other circuits (the First Circuit and the Second Circuit), reached polar opposite results. In addition, the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado found in 2021 that employees working as "Drilling Consultants" on natural gas and oil properties in Ohio and West Virginia, who were paid "at the very least $1,000 per day" and "were typically paid $1,400 or more for any day in which they worked," were paid on a salaried basis. Since they earned at least $200,000 per year, the district court in Colorado ruled that they were properly classified as exempt, highly compensated employees who were not entitled to overtime.

The battle is not over. With conflicts among the First, Second, and Fifth Circuits, as well as conflicting cases coming out of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, and the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, this may be an issue that will need to be resolved by the Supreme Court of the United States. In the meantime, the oil and gas industry is left to struggle in this unsettled environment.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mr Thomas A. Bright
Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak & Stewart
Peachtree Tower
191 Peachtree St NW #4800,
GA 30308
Tel: 404881-1300
E-mail: client.services@ogletreedeakins.com
URL: www.ogletree.com

© Mondaq Ltd, 2021 - Tel. +44 (0)20 8544 8300 - http://www.mondaq.com, source Business Briefing

10/22Tranche Update on Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc.'s Equity Buyback Plan announced on..
10/22HELIX ENERGY : Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of ..
10/21HELIX ENERGY : Press Release of Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. dated October 20, 2021 ..
10/21Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. Reports Earnings Results for the Third Quarter and N..
10/21HELIX ENERGY SOLUTIONS GROUP INC : Results of Operations and Financial Condition, Regulati..
10/21HELIX ENERGY : Swings to Q3 Loss, Revenue Declines
10/20HELIX ENERGY : Third Quarter 2021 Presentation
10/20HELIX ENERGY : Q3 Earnings Snapshot
10/20HELIX ENERGY : Reports Third Quarter 2021 Results
10/20Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. Reports Earnings Results for the Third Quarter and N..
More news
Analyst Recommendations on HELIX ENERGY SOLUTIONS GROUP, INC.
More recommendations
Financials (USD)
Sales 2021 644 M - -
Net income 2021 -80,6 M - -
Net Debt 2021 7,00 M - -
P/E ratio 2021 -7,01x
Yield 2021 -
Capitalization 588 M 588 M -
EV / Sales 2021 0,93x
EV / Sales 2022 0,84x
Nbr of Employees 1 536
Free-Float 94,0%
Duration : Period :
Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends HELIX ENERGY SOLUTIONS GROUP, INC.
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 8
Last Close Price 3,90 $
Average target price 5,43 $
Spread / Average Target 39,2%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Owen Eugene Kratz President, Chief Executive Officer & Director
Erik Staffeldt Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President
William L. Transier Chairman
Leigh Beck Chief Technology Officer & Vice President
Scott Andrew Sparks Chief Operating Officer & Executive Vice President
Sector and Competitors