What would be a fine for monopoly acts carried out by giant e-commerce platforms in the People's Republic of China?
Different cases may provide different answers. For the food delivery business platform
After a 7-months investigation, on
How did CNKI get into trouble with the Antitrust laws and authorities, and why should we care about this case?
CNKI stands for “China National Knowledge Infrastructure”, which is the main database platform controlling over 95% of the Chinese academic resources.
Its business model is similar to the one of
With the word “national” in its name, CNKI is usually considered an institute supported by governmental departments, so many colleges and universities cooperate with CNKI and buy its service. However, it is in fact a for-profit corporation owned by a public listed company.
As stated in the investigation report of SAMR, over 90% of college students and scholars use CNKI to prepare their essays or papers, thus CNKI requires them to give the exclusive right to publish and use relevant works after their essays or papers are completed.
It is no doubt that CNKI has acquired a dominant position in the market and its business practices have become more and more aggressive towards the users in recent years.
In
What may be deemed as monopoly in the P.R.C?
Following a thorough investigation, the SAMR found that the market concentration status shown by the Herfindahl-Hirschman index (HH index)1 of CNKI reached 5488 points, which is near the HH index of
Under the same investigation, the SAMR also found that CNKI held two monopoly behaviors, as complained by the university users:
1) continuing to rise its service fee with unjustifiable reason, and
2) obliging the authors to sign exclusive cooperation agreement to restrict the authors' authorization to other platforms. Such a situation lead to the fine imposed on CNKI.
The “P.R.C Anti-Monopoly Law” provides for 3 situations of monopoly. Apart from the “abuse of dominant market position” of CNKI mentioned above, the other two monopolistic behaviors include: “conclusion of a monopolistic agreement”, such as “coordination of prices”; and “concentration of undertakings that eliminates or restricts competition or may eliminate or restrict competition”. Such business behaviors are not rare to witness in our daily life.
How can the anti-monopoly law improve our future?
Consumers are harmed by monopolistic behaviors, and the cases of CNKI,
If the monopolistic behaviors are not limited, the market competition is restrained; then consumers will have no other choice than to use the services of enterprises operating as monopoly. This situation is economically unhealthy and unfair for both the consumers and other small-scale businesses wishing to enter or fairly compete in the market.
Thus, the anti-monopoly law aims at protecting the legitimate rights of the entities in the market, by improving and levelling the playing-field conditions, and the consumers which should benefit from a fairer competition between the market players. Influential cases like CNKI becoming more and more familiar to the public, both the consumers and the business entities will more easily notice how anti-monopoly laws tend to protect their rights.
What to do for the compliance?
The compliance responsibility mainly falls onto the business owners with significant market shares, especially when exceeding 30% percent. Such business entities should therefore avoid to fall into the three situations where their conduct may be deemed as monopolistic.
In general, business operators should keep in mind the following directions:
- when they are operating in a dominant position in a relevant market, not to abuse of such position,
- refrain from entering into monopolistic agreements, and
- check compliance with the antimonopoly laws before any mergers, acquisitions of shares or actual control over other commercial entities with similar business operation.
We understand that many details lie in the three situations, so the compliance check shall be a case-by-case procedure, and if you are interest in more details, please do not hesitate to reach us for further elaboration.
Footnote
1 The index measures the size of companies relative to the size of the industry they are in and the amount of competitiveness. The HHI is calculated by squaring the market share of each firm competing in a market and then summing the resulting numbers. It can range from nearly 0 to 10,000, an HHI of 2,500 or greater is highly concentrated.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Ms
HFG Law & Intellectual Property
14/F, Huaqi Building No. 969
200040
Tel: 21 5 213 5500
Fax: 215 213 0895
E-mail: ovarlamova@hfgip.com
URL: www.hfgip.com
© Mondaq Ltd, 2023 - Tel. +44 (0)20 8544 8300 - http://www.mondaq.com, source