Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 


SummaryMost relevantAll NewsAnalyst Reco.Other languagesPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsMarketScreener Strategies

Double Stock-Market Bubble Brings Toil and (Perhaps) Trouble

01/03/2021 | 10:15am EDT

By James Mackintosh

It is easy to spot bubbles. Too easy: They seem to be almost everywhere, almost all the time. Worse still for those of us who try to spot excess, much of the stuff that was labeled frothy in recent years went on to make big money in 2020 for those who bought into it anyway.

The question for investors: Were the bubble calls just wrong? Or are we in a new era of wild speculation driven by cheap money that must inevitably come to an end?

I lean toward the latter. But the stunning performance of so many bubble stocks this past year shows that even if this turns out to be right eventually, there is plenty of scope to be horribly wrong in the meantime.

For one example, consider the bubble portfolio created in mid-2017 by Paul McNamara, an emerging-market fund manager at GAM. Featuring stocks and bonds labeled as bubbles by the financial Twitter community that year, it includes Tesla, Netflix, Tencent, a bitcoin fund, Canadian apartments, London property and long-dated U.S., Japanese and Argentinian bonds. Only one -- the Argentinian 100-year bond -- is down since being selected, having lost almost all its value.

If you had spread $900 equally across the portfolio's nine holdings at the end of June 2017, you would now have more than $2,950, more than double what you would have got from the S&P 500. Remember, this was buying the stuff that many thought was already wildly overvalued.

Yet, the bubble-watchers were right on many of the stocks. Just not for long. Parts of Mr. McNamara's bubble portfolio appeared to burst, but then came roaring back in 2020. If there is a bubble, it is a double bubble.

The Grayscale Bitcoin Trust, which holds bitcoin for a 2% fee, dropped 90% from its 2017 peak, but in 2020 it almost quadrupled to again trade above the value of the bitcoin it holds.

Tesla stock was below its mid-2017 price for most of the next 2 1/2 years amid fights with regulators, fears about a cash shortage and missed production targets. Then it was electrified by the events of 2020, rising eightfold to become one of the largest companies in the world by market value.

Netflix and China's Tencent didn't reach their 2018 peaks again until they were boosted by lockdowns and cheap money on their way to a spectacular 2020.

Even some of the stocks that went through their own mini-bubbles and busts earlier in the decade returned to form last year.

The 2013 fad for 3-D printing turned out to be pure froth, and the leading exponent, 3D Systems, is down 89% from its high. In 2020, it rose 20%, outpacing the S&P.

The 2011 excitement about rare-earth elements gave birth to the VanEck Vectors Rare Earth/Strategic Metals ETF. It is down 81% from that year's high, but gained 63% in 2020.

Solar collapsed with oil during the 2008 financial crisis, but was still frothy at the start of 2010. The Invesco Solar ETF (amusing ticker alert: TAN) fell 81% from 2010's high, which was already down more than half from its pre-financial crisis high. This past year it more than tripled.

Cheap money often fuels speculative fervor, and this time has been helped by bored work-from-homers finding that day trading is a way to gamble their stimulus checks.

As usual the bubble stocks have a good story to tell about new technology and major shifts in consumption. They are helped by the superlow bond yields engineered by central banks. But their valuations and the scale of the price moves are extreme and probably unsustainable.

Probably. The danger for those of us calling out frothy markets isn't only that high prices could be justified by fast-growing profits, but that bubbles can always become more extreme. If you doubt that, just look at 2020.

Write to James Mackintosh at James.Mackintosh@wsj.com

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

01-03-21 1014ET

Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
3D SYSTEMS CORPORATION 2.11% 28.5341 Delayed Quote.166.70%
BITCOIN - EURO -8.98% 27394.47 Real-time Quote.27.18%
BITCOIN - UNITED STATES DOLLAR -8.67% 32628.33 Real-time Quote.23.42%
DJ INDUSTRIAL 1.73% 33861.61 Delayed Quote.8.77%
EXPONENT, INC. 2.64% 88.33 Delayed Quote.-4.41%
INVESCO LTD. 2.48% 26.895 Delayed Quote.50.60%
LONDON BRENT OIL 1.74% 74.88 Delayed Quote.41.20%
NASDAQ 100 0.54% 14121.915704 Delayed Quote.9.01%
NASDAQ COMP. 0.70% 14125.798751 Delayed Quote.8.86%
NETFLIX, INC. -0.83% 496.29 Delayed Quote.-7.40%
S&P 500 1.32% 4220.99 Delayed Quote.10.93%
TENCENT HOLDINGS LIMITED 0.67% 603 End-of-day quote.6.91%
TESLA, INC. -0.22% 621.5596 Delayed Quote.-11.67%
TWITTER, INC. 1.50% 61.7602 Delayed Quote.12.37%
WTI 2.40% 73.508 Delayed Quote.48.21%
All news about TWITTER, INC.
03:43pBofA Securities Identifies 2021 Internet and e-Commerce Events, and Who Stand..
03:19pBofA Securities Highlights Industry Events, Product Launches, and Legislative..
03:18pSTREET COLOR : BofA Securities Highlights Industry Events, Product Launches, and..
03:07pTWITTERá : gaming and esports insights for the first half of 2021
02:06aTWITTERá : SERAP Sues Nigerian Govt, Lai Mohammed Over 'Repressive' Directive to..
06/17INSIDER TRENDS : 90-Day Insider Buying Trend Reduced with Disposition of Twitter..
06/15MARKET CHATTER : Amazon, Walmart's Flipkart Face Demands for Data as India Speed..
06/15TWITTERá : A new Arabic language setting, from غرّد to &..
06/10INSIDER TRENDS : Insider Disposition Eases Back 90-Day Buy Trend at Twitter
06/09TWITTERá : Mimi Alemayhou to join the Board, bringing more than 20 years of inve..
More news
Financials (USD)
Sales 2021 4 788 M - -
Net income 2021 157 M - -
Net cash 2021 5 089 M - -
P/E ratio 2021 333x
Yield 2021 -
Capitalization 48 445 M 48 445 M -
EV / Sales 2021 9,05x
EV / Sales 2022 7,23x
Nbr of Employees 5 500
Free-Float 97,5%
Duration : Period :
Twitter, Inc. Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends TWITTER, INC.
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 41
Average target price 64,40 $
Last Close Price 60,85 $
Spread / Highest target 56,1%
Spread / Average Target 5,84%
Spread / Lowest Target -50,7%
EPS Revisions
Managers and Directors
Jack Dorsey Chief Executive Officer & Director
Ned D. Segal Chief Financial Officer
Patrick Pichette Chairman
Parag Agrawal Chief Technology Officer
Dantley Davis Head-Research & Design
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
TWITTER, INC.12.37%48 445
FACEBOOK INC20.68%934 739
MATCH GROUP, INC.1.81%41 649
BUMBLE INC.0.00%6 019
NEW WORK SE-3.04%1 809