In the letter, Charming Shoppes noted, among other things: -- Charming Shoppes' Board has a proven record of managing successfully through challenging retail and economic environments by making tough, but necessary, decisions to position the Company for sustainable and profitable growth. -- In the current environment, Charming Shoppes' Board and management team are focused on maintaining a solid balance sheet and optimizing cash flow generation to ensure the Company's continued financial strength and long-term competitiveness. -- Crescendo and Myca have offered no new ideas to benefit the Company and its shareholders and are only advocating a short-term financial reengineering scheme for Charming Shoppes, including sales of Company assets and a diversion of cash flow necessary to run its business, all with the goal of a one-time share buyback.
Charming Shoppes strongly urges shareholders to reject the three individuals nominated by the dissident shareholder group in opposition to Charming Shoppes' incumbent directors.
The full text of Charming Shoppes' letter follows: WHO DO YOU WANT LEADING CHARMING SHOPPES IN TODAY'S CHALLENGING RETAIL AND ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT? SEASONED DIRECTORS AND RETAIL APPAREL EXECUTIVES OR OPPORTUNISTIC HEDGE FUND MANAGERS? WE BELIEVE THE ANSWER IS CLEAR -- SUPPORT CHARMING SHOPPES' BOARD OF DIRECTORS -- VOTE THE GOLD PROXY CARD TODAY April 17, 2008
Dear Fellow Shareholder:
By now you may have received a letter from a dissident shareholder group
led by two small
We urge you to reject the dissident group's nominees and re-elect Charming
Shoppes' experienced and highly-qualified directors --
YOUR BOARD AND MANAGEMENT TEAM KNOW HOW TO MANAGE SUCCESSFULLY THROUGH
CHALLENGING RETAIL AND ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENTS
Your Board and management team have a proven record of navigating through difficult economic environments by making tough, but necessary, decisions to position the Company for sustainable and profitable growth with the goal of enhancing value for all shareholders.
During the last economic downturn in 2002 and 2003, your Board and management team implemented a series of initiatives to control inventory, reduce overhead costs, refocus the growth of core brands through merchandising and store execution, and further developed Lane Bryant -- Charming Shoppes' primary growth vehicle today, which had been acquired in 2001. Through these efforts, from 2003 to 2006, Charming Shoppes successfully increased top-line growth, improved operating margins from 3.2% to 5.6%, and grew EBITDA margins from 7.4% to 8.6%. In the three fiscal years following the 2002-2003 downturn, the Company's share price appreciated 275%, outpacing both our peers (+231%) and the S&P 500 Index (+50%). In the five fiscal years following the downturn, Charming Shoppes' stock price increased 105% -- outperforming both its peers (+43%) and the S&P 500 Index (+63%).
By positioning Charming Shoppes as a strong, healthy competitor with a leading market position, your Board and management team have demonstrated they are best-suited to lead the Company in the current environment and enhance shareholder value in the future.
YOUR BOARD AND MANAGEMENT TEAM HAVE TAKEN DECISIVE ACTIONS AND ARE COMMITTED TO DRIVING SUSTAINABLE AND PROFITABLE GROWTH
Over the last year, Charming Shoppes has streamlined business operations, reduced SG&A expenses and capital expenditures, and improved cash flow. We have:
-- Consolidated retail operating and marketing functions and eliminated approximately 200 full-time corporate and field management positions; -- Commenced a process to close approximately 150 underperforming stores this year, including about 100 stores at the Fashion Bug chain, as well as the Petite Sophisticate retail concept; -- Improved inventory management and implemented aggressive promotional activities, which resulted in a 19% reduction in same store inventories for the fiscal year ended February 2, 2008; and -- Limited the number of planned store openings, which resulted in a $40 million, or 30%, reduction in the Company's 2008 capital budget from 2007 levels.
Your Board unanimously believes that continued execution of Charming Shoppes' focused multi-brand, multi-channel strategy is the best course of action to strengthen our leadership position in our specialty retail markets, and thereby enhance long-term shareholder value. We continue to:
-- Focus on our core brands -- Lane Bryant, Catherines and Fashion Bug -- by improving the merchandise selection through a variety of new initiatives such as Right Fit by Lane Bryant(TM) and Cacique(R) intimate apparel, Right Fit by Catherines(TM), and securing the exclusive use of the Gitano(R) brand name for sportswear and footwear at Fashion Bug; -- Shift sales and profit mix to higher operating margin brands and channels; and -- Utilize our newly launched Lane Bryant catalog business and e-commerce platform to better serve our loyal and growing customer base.
In the current environment, your Board and management team are focused on maintaining a solid balance sheet and optimizing cash flow generation, to ensure the Company's continued financial strength and long-term competitiveness:
-- We are operating the business with a focus on cash flow generation in order to maintain significant financial flexibility and appropriate liquidity; -- We continue to maintain an optimal and cost effective capital structure. We refinanced our convertible notes with more cost effective, longer term convertible debt and decreased our annual interest expense by over $4 million. This has provided us with new low-cost 7-year financing that eliminates any short-term refinancing needs and allows us to focus on operating and business initiatives without any significant financing limitations; and -- Over the last 12 months, we have returned significant capital to our shareholders through the repurchase of $253 million of common stock.
Ask yourself, in today's difficult retail and economic environment, who do you want leading your Company -- an experienced and highly-qualified Board and management team with a proven track record of taking decisive actions and managing through challenging environments, or opportunistic hedge fund managers who have no large public company retail experience and limited strategic, operational and management experience?
CRESCENDO AND MYCA OFFER NO NEW IDEAS FOR CHARMING SHOPPES
We believe the dissident hedge fund group is merely attempting to turn a quick profit on its Charming Shoppes stock, most of which was bought last December at prices depressed by the current economic environment.
To date, the dissident group has not articulated any new ideas to navigate your Company through the current economic environment. Instead, they have put forth stale rhetoric taken directly out of the activist hedge fund playbook from the past. The Crescendo and Myca hedge funds -- as they have done at other publicly-traded companies -- are advocating a short-term financial reengineering scheme at Charming Shoppes, including sales of Company assets and the diversion of cash flow necessary to run the business, which we believe would present significant risk to Charming Shoppes, all with the goal of having a one-time share buyback.
We believe these highly risky propositions are imprudent, especially in light of the current environment, and, in our opinion, reflect the dissident group's lack of understanding of Charming Shoppes, the retail industry and the credit markets today.
We strongly believe the dissident group's director nominees, if elected, will seek to advance the hedge funds' risky short-term financial reengineering scheme and be highly disruptive to the efforts of your Board and management team to create long-term shareholder value.
PROTECT THE VALUE OF YOUR INVESTMENT - RE-ELECT YOUR DIRECTORS - VOTE THE GOLD PROXY CARD TODAY
Your vote is important, no matter how many or how few shares you own. To vote your shares, please sign, date and return the enclosed GOLD proxy card by mailing it in the enclosed pre-addressed, stamped envelope. You may also vote by phone or Internet by following the instructions on the enclosed proxy card. If you have any questions or need any assistance voting your shares, please contact MacKenzie Partners, Inc., which is assisting the Company in this matter, toll-free at (800) 322-2885 or charming@mackenziepartners.com.
On behalf of the Board of Directors, we thank you for your continued support of Charming Shoppes.
Sincerely, /s/ /s/ Dorrit J. Bern Katherine M. Hudson Chairman, Chief Executive Officer and President Lead Independent Director
At
FORWARD-LOOKING LANGUAGE
This press release contains certain forward-looking statements concerning
the Company's operations, performance, and financial condition. Such forward-
looking statements are subject to various risks and uncertainties that could
cause actual results to differ materially from those indicated. Such risks and
uncertainties may include, but are not limited to: the failure to effectively
implement the Company's plans for consolidation of the Catherines Plus Sizes
brand, a new organizational structure and enhancements in the Company's
merchandise and marketing, the failure to generate a positive response to the
Company's new Lane Bryant catalog and the Lane Bryant credit card program, the
failure to implement the Company's business plan for increased profitability
and growth in the Company's retail stores and direct-to-consumer segments, the
failure to successfully implement the Company's expansion of Cacique through
new store formats, the failure of changes in management to achieve improvement
in the Company's competitive position, the failure to successfully implement
the Company's integration of operations of, and the business plan for,
Crosstown Traders, Inc., adverse changes in costs vital to catalog operations,
such as postage, paper and acquisition of prospects, declining response rates
to catalog offerings, failure to maintain efficient and uninterrupted order-
taking and fulfillment in our direct-to-consumer business, changes in or
miscalculation of fashion trends, extreme or unseasonable weather conditions,
economic downturns, escalation of energy costs, a weakness in overall consumer
demand, failure to find suitable store locations, increases in wage rates, the
ability to hire and train associates, trade and security restrictions and
political or financial instability in countries where goods are manufactured,
the interruption of merchandise flow from the Company's centralized
distribution facilities, competitive pressures, and the adverse effects of
natural disasters, war, acts of terrorism or threats of either, or other armed
conflict, on
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
On
SOURCE Charming Shoppes, Inc.