Item 5.02 Departure of Directors or Certain Officers; Election of Directors;
Appointment of Certain Officers; Compensatory Arrangements of Certain Officers.
Announcement of Resignation of Director
On April 10, 2023, Mr. Charles W. Winters II resigned as a director of Alpine 4
Holdings, Inc. (the "Company"), effective at the end of that same day. Mr.
Winters' notice of resignation was conveyed in a letter of resignation (the
"Resignation Letter"), a copy of which is attached to this Current Report on
Form 8-K as Exhibit 17.1. In his Resignation Letter, Mr. Winters stated that he
had serious concerns regarding the operations, policies, and practices of the
Company. The Company disputes the claims made by Mr. Winters in his Resignation
Letter, including his characterizations of the Company, the Board, the CEO, and
other Company management.
Mr. Winters' criticisms expressed in the Resignation Letter are ones he first
voiced as early as 13 months ago, beginning around the time his position as a
sales executive with the Company was terminated for cause, and also after the
Company Board adopted a rotating chairmanship that meant Mr. Winters would at
present no longer be chairman. When Mr. Winters' claims were originally raised,
Company CEO Kent Wilson directed that an independent outside investigation be
instituted, and thereafter the well-regarded independent investigatory law firm
Littler Mendelson, P.C. ("Littler") was engaged to investigate Mr. Winters'
claims and to review the appropriateness of his termination for cause from his
sales position. In addition, the Board convened two special committees of
independent dis-interested board members, one to review claims in which the
Company and its auditor agreed that good governance required further
investigation into the possible validity of the claims, and one to review
evidence of concerning conduct by Mr. Winters that appeared to violate the
fiduciary duty that Mr. Winters owed to the Company and its Board. The Littler
and the Special Committees' investigatory efforts arrived at the conclusions
that Mr. Winters' claims of problems in the operations, policies, and practices
of the Company were unfounded, that the termination of his employment with the
Company as a sales executive was justified, and that he had engaged in conduct
that violated his fiduciary duty to the Company and the Board, and moreover that
there is evidence that these violations of fiduciary duty were committed in bad
faith. Copies of various reports generated during these investigations were
shared with Mr. Winters, including an executive summary of the Littler report.
These efforts of investigation and review culminated in a Special Committee of
the Board resolution, dated September 8th, 2022, sanctioning Mr. Winters.
Quoting from that resolution in relevant part:
WHEREAS the Special Committee finds that the evidence presented in the reports
are persuasive that Director Winters' conduct was actionable as violations under
the Company and Board rules and policies for comportment of employees and Board
members; and
WHEREAS the Special Committee finds that the evidence presented in the reports
are persuasive that Director Winters' and his counsel's allegations of Company
and Board malfeasance are without merit, and moreover were alleged by Director
Winters in bad faith; and
WHEREAS Director Winters' conduct in violation of Company and Board policies and
in breach of his fiduciary duties has unfoundedly jeopardized the Company's
position with its outside auditors, threatened to cause missed SEC filing
deadlines, unduly risked exposure to (i) unfounded shareholder lawsuits, (ii)
liability for unfair labor practices, and (iii) unwarranted stock price decline,
and to date has cost the Company over $100,000 in expenses and many hours of
diverted Company management and Board attention;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that based on these recitals, the Special
Committee of the Board of Directors proclaims that it strongly disapproves of
the aforementioned conduct of Director Winters, and in response to his conduct
that violated policies stated in the Company's Corporate Governance and Code
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
of Business Conduct guidelines and the Employee Handbook, that violated the
terms of the Founding Director Agreement signed by Director Winters, and that
breached the duties of care, loyalty, and good faith that a Director owes to the
Company and to the Board, the Special Committee hereby CENSURES Director Charles
Winters, and admonishes him to cease and desist conduct that violates his
fiduciary obligations as a Board member; and
IT IS RESOLVED FURTHER that the Special Committee, in its power to invoke
penalties, does hereby exclude Director Winters from all Board committee and
representative assignments, from serving as an officer of the Board, and from
any official travel on Board business; and
IT IS RESOLVED FURTHER that the Special Committee calls on Director Winters to
engage in discussions regarding terms of his resignation from the Board, and in
that matter, the Special Committee hereby authorizes Company management to
negotiate with Director Winters on the Board's behalf;
In consequence of this sanctioning by the Board, as of the date of his
resignation Mr. Winters did not hold any position on any committees of the
Board. Also, in consequence of this sanctioning, Mr. Winters was not nominated
to the slate of board members proposed for shareholder approval at the
forthcoming annual shareholders meeting on April 18th, 2023.
Negotiations regarding Mr. Winters' possible early departure from the Board
commenced soon after adoption of the resolution by the Special Committee.
However, the Company would not accede to Mr. Winters' monetary demands, and
would not accede even when made aware a resignation letter that the Company must
publish would be forthcoming otherwise, culminating in negotiations breaking off
on April 10th, 2023, and that same day Mr. Winters submitted his Resignation
Letter.
The Company has provided Mr. Winters with a copy of this Current Report on Form
8-K, and has advised him of his opportunity to furnish the Company as promptly
as possible with a letter stating whether he agrees with the statements made in
this Current Report on Form 8-K, and, if not, stating the respects in which he
does not agree. The Company will file any letter received from Mr. Winters as an
exhibit by an amendment to this Current Report on Form 8-K as and to the extent
required by Item 5.02(a) (3) of Form 8-K.
Item 9.01 Financial Statements and Exhibits
(d) Exhibits
Exhibit Number Description
104 Cover Page Interactive Data File (formatted as Inline XBRL)
17.1 Resignation Letter
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Edgar Online, source Glimpses