Log in
Forgot password ?
Become a member for free
Sign up
Sign up
New member
Sign up for FREE
New customer
Discover our services
Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Nyse  >  Exxon Mobil Corporation    XOM


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsPress ReleasesOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

Exxon Mobil Resists Write-Downs as Oil, Gas Prices Plummet

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
06/30/2020 | 09:10am EDT

By Christopher M. Matthews

As its peers write down U.S. shale assets by billions of dollars amid lower oil and gas prices, Exxon Mobil Corp. stands increasingly alone in not adjusting the value of its holdings.

Rivals, including BP PLC, Hess Corp. and Occidental Petroleum Corp., have recently taken multibillion-dollar impairments as a coronavirus-induced economic slowdown adds pressure to an already struggling shale sector. Chevron Corp. took a $10 billion write-down in December, and Royal Dutch Shell PLC said Tuesday that it would write down the value of its assets by up to $22 billion because of lower energy prices.

Exxon has yet to write down any shale assets this year, holding to a belief that oil and gas values will eventually rebound. Several oil and gas accounting experts allege that Exxon's reticence to adjust the value of shale assets on its balance sheet amounts to accounting fraud. In a series of complaints filed to U.S. authorities, they argue that the company is deceiving investors by failing to write down much of the value of XTO Energy Inc., a natural-gas driller it purchased for $31 billion a decade ago, along with other assets.

Exxon's refusal to write down its acquisition of XTO is part of an "arrogant, aberrant, long-standing...posture" at the company, said one of the accountants, Franklin Bennett, a former senior accounting analyst in Exxon's oil and gas business, in a complaint filed under the Securities and Exchange Commission's whistleblower program that was viewed by The Wall Street Journal. Mr. Bennett left Exxon in 1995, well before the XTO deal, but maintains the company's accounting of the acquisition fits with its past practice of handling assets that might be worth less than anticipated.

An Exxon spokesman said the company is in compliance with accounting rules and SEC regulations about disclosures to investors.

When Exxon announced its plans to acquire XTO in December 2009, the company's second-largest deal ever, U.S. natural-gas prices averaged $5.35 per million British thermal units. But over the past five years, gas prices have mostly stayed below $3/MMBtu.

Gas prices hit a 25-year low last week, then notched an 11% gain Monday, closing at $1.71/MMBtu. Future contracts for U.S. natural gas average about $2.50/MMBtu or lower for the next four years. BP estimated in February that U.S. gas prices could be around $2/MMBtu for the next 20 years.

"We probably paid too much," former Exxon Chief Executive Rex Tillerson said of the XTO deal at a conference last year.

Exxon wrote down the value of U.S. shale gas assets by $2.5 billion in late 2017. Critics of the company, including some analysts, have questioned whether that was sufficient, noting the price of the XTO deal.

The U.S. shale industry has written down more than $450 billion in assets since 2010, according to a June report by Deloitte, reassessing holdings amid a global supply glut and growing investor concerns about the long-term future of fossil fuels. The accounting firm projects additional shale impairments of as much as $300 billion in coming months as the coronavirus holds down commodity prices.

Exxon has announced about $6.5 billion in write downs since 2014, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence, far less than similarly sized competitors. Chevron has taken $16.7 billion in impairments during the same period.

Mr. Bennett, a practicing securities-law attorney, served as a committee chairman for the professional society for oil and gas accountants in the U.S. and Canada. He first filed a complaint with the SEC in 2015, which he said was based on his knowledge of historic Exxon accounting practices and analysis of its disclosures. He and a group of accountants, including a former partner in the oil and gas practice of a major U.S. accounting firm, have subsequently sent the regulator 30 supplements, including one this month, according to documents viewed by the Journal.

He said in the complaint that Exxon should be writing down the value of XTO by at least $17 billion and impairing at least $20 billion in other assets, depending on how it has booked the details. He also has sent his complaint to the Justice Department.

Under the SEC's whistleblower program, which covers more than cases involving firsthand claims of wrongdoing, Mr. Bennett could be compensated if the government takes action on his complaint. Tipsters can receive between 10% and 30% of any penalty collected as a result of providing original information.

Casey Norton, an Exxon spokesman, said the company's accounting practices withstood scrutiny when Exxon won a case in 2019 in which it was accused by New York's attorney general of failing to inform investors about the impact of climate change on its assets. He noted that the SEC also had dropped a similar investigation about whether Exxon misled investors on climate-change disclosures in 2018.

"Exxon Mobil's record on impairments and our rigorous and consistent process for testing for impairments have been repeatedly scrutinized and upheld," Mr. Norton said.

The SEC and the Justice Department declined to comment.

Exxon has long played down questions about its lack of asset write-downs, saying it is able to avoid them because it is extremely conservative in initially booking the value of new fields and wells and doesn't respond to short-term commodity-price fluctuations. Before 2016, Exxon had never recognized an asset impairment under U.S. accounting rules implemented in the 1990s.

The XTO complaint isn't the first time Mr. Bennett has contested the company's write-down policies. He was part of a 2004 lawsuit involving the Ohio state pension system and others who alleged that Exxon's failure to impair its properties undercut shareholders of Mobil Corp. in the 1999 deal that combined the companies.

Exxon denied the allegations. A federal judge dismissed the suit, finding the plaintiff's didn't sufficiently allege a fraud, and an appeals court upheld the dismissal because the statute of limitations on such claims had passed.

Write to Christopher M. Matthews at christopher.matthews@wsj.com


Stocks mentioned in the article
ChangeLast1st jan.
EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION 0.02% 42.66 Delayed Quote.-38.88%
HESS CORPORATION 0.96% 45.33 Delayed Quote.-32.79%
WTI -1.18% 39.635 Delayed Quote.-35.40%
share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
07/09CONOIL : Qatar Petroleum wins 'New Venturer of the Year' award
07/09Energy industry veterans to launch hydrogen investment fund
07/08EXXON MOBIL : Security remains our priority - Sanwo-Olu
07/07Canadian oil companies take go-slow approach to recovery as prices improve
07/07Coronavirus pain drives Big Oil's dash for record debt
07/06NEWS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Energy News of the Day
07/06NEWS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Energy News of the Day
07/06NEWS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Energy News of the Day
07/06NEWS HIGHLIGHTS : Top Energy News of the Day
More news
Financials (USD)
Sales 2020 185 B - -
Net income 2020 -2 680 M - -
Net Debt 2020 59 098 M - -
P/E ratio 2020 -50,6x
Yield 2020 8,18%
Capitalization 180 B 180 B -
EV / Sales 2019
EV / Sales 2020 1,30x
Nbr of Employees 74 900
Free-Float 52,7%
Duration : Period :
Exxon Mobil Corporation Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus HOLD
Number of Analysts 24
Average target price 48,90 $
Last Close Price 42,66 $
Spread / Highest target 80,5%
Spread / Average Target 14,6%
Spread / Lowest Target -20,3%
EPS Revisions
Darren W. Woods Chairman & Chief Executive Officer
Andrew P. Swiger Chief Financial Officer & Senior VP
Samuel J. Palmisano Independent Director
Steven S. Reinemund Independent Director
Kenneth C. Frazier Independent Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
BP PLC-38.34%74 012
PTT-14.77%34 889
NESTE OYJ14.89%30 960